Research Abstracts
Presented at the 2001 Annual Meeting of the
American Association of Family and Consumer Sciences in Providence,
Rhode Island
Edited by Beth Wuest, Ph.D.
Co-Chair of Colleges, Universities and Research Section
Oral Presentation Session
1. The Teen Consumer: Understanding Interaction
Styles and Marketing Attitudes
Christy Crutsinger and Dee Knight, University of North Texas
2. The Design Connection
Diana Cone, Georgia Southern University
3. Student Perceptions of Teaching Evaluations
Sue Couch, Texas Tech University
4. Comparison of Fat Free and Regular Potato
Chips: Gastrointestinal Symptoms in Female College Students
Jay Kandiah and E. Wendt, Ball State University
5. Application of Universal and Lighting Design
Kenneth Tremblay, Chia-rung Lin and Li-Lin Candy Yang, Colorado
State University
6. The Impact of Perceived Power, Attraction
and Attachment Style on the Breakups of Committed Premarital
Relationships
Jana L. Pendleton and Maribeth Clarke, Brigham Young University
7. Childhood Financial Influences and Personal
Finance Behaviors
Barbara O'Neill and Patricia Brennan, Rutgers University
Jing Xiao and Claudia Kerbel, University of Rhode Island
Barbara Bristow, Cornell University
Research Poster Session
Apparel and Textiles
8. Retailers' Perceptions of Apparel and Home
Furnishings Vendors
Lynn Brandon, Dee Knight, and Christy Crutsinger, University
of North Texas
9. Impact of Consumption Experiences on Clothing
Purchase Attitudes: A Cross-National Study
Jessie H. Chen-Yu, Virginia Tech
Keum-Hee Hong, Silla University
10. Adoption of the Internet for Apparel Shopping
by College Students
Cynthia R. Easterling and Dolly Loyd, The University of Southern
Mississippi
11. Influence of Lifestyle Orientation on
Information Search, Evaluation, and Purchase of Casual
Apparel and Home Furnishings Products
Judith C. Forney and Lynn Brandon, University of North Texas
12. Preserving and Indexing Textiles from
the Fag El Gamous Cemetery in Egypt to Facilitate Their
Comparison with Known Coptic Textiles
Rachel P. Hiatt, Maribeth C. Clarke, CFCS, Marvin C. J. Kunchar,
Brigham Young University
13. Furs: Controversy and Conservation
Catherine Amoroso Leslie, The Ohio State University
14. Fashion Groups and Fashion Problem Recognition
Style
Cathryn M. Studak and Jane E. Workman, Southern Illinois
University
15. Biodegradation Assessment of Cotton, Rayon
and Tencel Fabrics
Mary Warnock, Duane Wolf, and Karon Davis, University of
Arkansas
16. Ownership and Visibility of Alcohol Promotional
Clothing Items
Jane E. Workman, Naomi Arseneau, Chandra Ewell, and Kristen
Young, Southern Illinois University
17. Purchase Motivations and Product Satisfaction
of Single Women: Do Children Make a Difference
Lynn Brandon and Judith C. Forney, University of North Texas
18. Mature Consumers' Service Needs: Comparing
Perceptions of Mature Consumers and Apparel Retailers
Beth Wuest, Southwest Texas State University
Communication
19. A Value-Added Approach to Learning
Diane Cone and Diane Phillips, Georgia Southern University
Education and Technology
20. Empathy Levels of Adolescents Enrolled
in the Ohio High School Family and Consumer Sciences Program
Karen L. Alexander, University of Kentucky
Jerelyn B. Schultz, The Ohio State University
21. Characteristics of Family and Consumer
Sciences Teachers Related to Attitudes Toward Using Computers
as an Instructional Medium
Sheri L. Lokken and Wanda K. Cheek, Mississippi State University
Shirley W. Hastings, University of Tennessee
22. Gender as a Factor in Cognitive Style
of Professionals in Family and Consumer Science Fields
Barbara L. Stewart, Robert Fritz, and Marcella Norwood, University
of Houston
23. Principal's Perception of Female Teachers
Dress on Teaching Effectiveness
Janie O. Kenner, Rachel A. Underwood, and Sandra McClune,
Stephen F. Austin State University
Family Economics and Resource Management
24. Why Shop There if You Can Get It Here
Linda Simpson, Jane Wayland, and Barbara Kemmerer, Eastern
Illinois University
25. Living, Working, Parenting, and Section
8
Marilyn J. Bruin, University of Minnesota
Housing and Environment
26. Dishwashing Practices and Water Usage
JoAnn Emmel, Julia Beamish, and Kathleen Parrott, Virginia
Tech
27. Sociological and Consumer Dimensions of
the Midwifery Movement
Kelly Shannon Manley, University of Georgia
Michallene G. McDaniel, State University of West Georgia
28. Socioeconomic Status and Housing Values
of Korean Households
Sehwa Yang, Myojung Kim and Jinseon Hur
29. Appliance Disposal by Japanese Consumers
Pat McCallister, Eastern Illinois University
Nutrition, Health, and Food Management
30. Estimated Average Daily Intakes of Dietary
Energy and Fat Do Not Differ Between Self-Reported Chronic
Dieters and Non-Dieters
Jeannemarie M. Beiseigel and Sharon M. Nickols-Richarson,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
31. Alternative Medicine Practices of Nutrition
and Exercise Students
Barbara A. Davis, W. Tim Roberts, and F.A. Bruce Jr., Virginia
Tech
32. Who in the US is Consuming Functional
Foods?
Jeannette Endres and Sharon Barter, Southern Illinois University
33. Is Food Safety Knowledge Put into Practice
by Consumers in Middle Tennessee?
Sandria L. Godwin, Thelma Sanders-Hunter, and Leslie Speller-Henderson,
Tennessee State University
34. Prevalence of Food Insecurity and Dietary
Practice of Low Income Persons Participating in Food Assistance
Program
Nweze Nnakwe, Illinois State University
35. Quality of Life and Nutrition Risk in
Elderly Home-Delivered Meal Recipients and a Waiting List
Group
Elaine S. Smith, Alice A. Spangler, and Rebecca A. Adams,
Ball State University
36. The Use of an Instant Modified Food Starch
in Creating a Reduced Sugar Raspberry Jam
Janet C. Stocks, Maribeth C. Clarke, and Carolyn Garrison,
Brigham Young University
Family Relations and Human Development
37. Families as Potential Obstacles to End-of-Life
Care
Maribeth C. Clarke, CFCS, Renea L. Beckstrand, Laura N. Conover,
CFCS, Brigham Young University
38. Adolescents and Conflict with Peers: Relationships
between Personality Factors and Conflict Resolution Strategies
Debra Ann DeBates, Iowa State University
39. The Influence of Affluence on Gen-Xer's
Carma Sutherland and Janiel Nelson, Ricks College
1.
THE TEEN CONSUMER: INTERACTION STYLES AND MARKETING ATTITUDES
Christy Crutsinger and Dee Knight, University of North
Texas
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to investigate
the relationships between teens' consumer interaction styles
and attitudes toward marketing practices.
Procedures. Data were collected from teens (N=467)
during intact classes. Consumer interaction styles were measured
using Richin's (1983) 21-item, 5-point Likert scale. The
sample was divided into four interaction styles (i.e.,
non-assertive, assertive, aggressive, resort-to-aggression)
based on teens' scores. Gaski and Etzel's (1986) 20-item
scale measured teens' attitudes toward marketing practices.
Subscales corresponded to the four marketing mix elements: product,
pricing, advertising, and retailing. Participants
responded to items on a 5-point Likert scale. One-way ANOVAs
determined differences between consumer interaction styles
and attitudes toward marketing practices. All tests used
a .05 alpha level.
Findings. ANOVAs revealed that aggressive teens
had less positive attitudes toward products [F=(3,
436)=19.83, p <.001] and more positive attitudes
toward pricing [F=(3, 4 14)=10.28, p < .001]
than teens in the other groups. The Scheffe post hoc
comparison test revealed that aggressive(M=15.03)
teens held more negative attitudes toward product quality than
the other groups. Further post hoc comparisons revealed
that aggressive teens (M=14.32) had more positive
attitudes toward pricing than those in the other groups. Additional
ANOVA testing revealed a significant difference between assertive teens
and attitudes toward retailing [F=(3, 434)=9.77, p <.001]
and advertising [F=(3, 411)=3.82, p <.05]. Post
hoc comparisons revealed that assertive (M=17.71)
teens had more positive attitudes toward retailing than
the other groups. Furthermore, assertive (M=15.05)
teens had more positive attitudes toward advertising than
teens who resort-to-aggression (M=13.63).
Implications. Although most teens had positive
views toward marketing practices, aggressive teens were more
likely to have negative attitudes toward the product component
of the marketing mix. Because aggressive individuals
are generally more intimidating in their actions and have
more negative perceptions of others, one might assume that
their hostility would translate into negative attitudes toward
businesses (i.e., products). However, a surprising
finding showed that aggressive teens revealed positive attitudes
toward pricing. This might be explained by the fact
that aggressive teens may seek out retail formats that offer
the best price. Assertive teens, in this study, were
more likely to have positive attitudes toward retailing and
advertising. Perhaps assertive individuals are more
likely to request and receive help from a company when a
problem arises. Therefore, over time, assertive individuals
experience more positive interactions with businesses, which
would ultimately lead to more positive attitudes.
References.
Gaski, J. F., and Etzel, M. J. (1986). The
index of consumer sentiment toward marketing. Journal of
Marketing, 50, 71-81.
Richins, M. L. (1983). An analysis of consumer interaction
styles in the marketplace. Journal of Consumer Research, 10, 73-82.
2.
THE DESIGN CONNECTION
Diana Cone, Georgia Southern University
Purpose. Today's graduates are expected to
enter the new millennium as competent citizens ready to manage
the challenges of living and working in a diverse and global
society. The purpose of the exploratory project was
to develop an awareness of the influences of cultural diversity
in interiors by using visual images as a way of proclaiming
specific cultural values and to recognize symbolic associations
characterized by cultural customs.
Procedures. Pre-test questionnaires were administered
to 40 students enrolled in a sophomore level Design Appreciation
course at a regional university in the southeast to determine
their understanding of cultural traditions and customs that
influence interior spaces. The results were used to
develop an exploratory project to facilitate an understanding
of cultural diversity and an appreciation of the distinctiveness
of individuals and how they contribute to society.
Post-test questionnaires were used to evaluate the project
and the cultural awareness among the students.
Findings. Data from the pre-test revealed little
knowledge among the participants about cultural preferences
and customs for interior furnishings with cultures other
than their own. The exploratory project required that
small groups of students (two or three) conduct an in-depth
study of a selected cultural group and access information
from a variety of sources about the customs and preferences
that affect interior spaces (color, space, furniture styles,
climate, technology, economy, lifestyle, etc.). The
information gathered was used to write a cultural profile
for the group studied and to create a model of an interior
space which reflects these preferences. An oral presentation
of the findings were presented by each group to the entire
class. Post-project evaluations indicated a higher
level of awareness of cultural diversity among the class. Specifically,
students felt better able to transfer information on cultural
diversity to current interior design practices.
Implications. This project spotlighted the need
for multi-cultural education in the curriculum to facilitate
an understanding of cultural diversity and an appreciation
of the distinctiveness of various groups of people. Continued
efforts are necessary to encourage students to seek a new
vision of cultural pluralism that supports cross-cultural
understanding while promoting global awareness.
3.
STUDENT PERCEPTIONS OF TEACHING EVALUATIONS
Sue Couch, Texas Tech University
The purpose of the study was to assess student perceptions
of teaching and how it is evaluated. The study was
part of a campus-wide self-study on evaluating teaching,
conducted at a research university in the southwest and supported
by a grant from the W.K. Kellogg Foundation. The goals
of the self-study were to document institutional strengths
in evaluating and rewarding teaching and identify areas needing
improvement.
The self-study was based on ten standards for evaluating
teaching, developed by the Kellogg Foundation's Collective
Leadership Project for Change.
Undergraduate and graduate students were surveyed to determine
their perceptions of the student role in evaluating teaching. Students
were asked to rate the importance of 23 dimensions of teaching
effectiveness (not important=1, very important=5) and utilized
a Likert-type scale, strongly disagree (1) to strongly agree
(5), to respond to statements related to student evaluation
of teaching. The survey also included open-ended items
and provided an opportunity for comments. The survey
was distributed in classes by faculty volunteers in each
of the university's eight colleges and schools. College
of Human Sciences majors accounted for about 18% of the responding
sample (420 of 2, 353).
Students rated all 23 dimensions of teaching effectiveness
as important or very important. Those rated as most
important were Teacher is knowledgeable about subject (4.64),
Grading is fair and impartial (4.54), Teacher is well prepared
(4.52), and Teacher shows concern and respect for students
(4.50). Although students did not believe that appropriate
dimensions of teaching effectiveness had been defined by
the institution (3.37) or that the current student course
evaluation form allowed an accurate assessment of teaching
effectiveness (3.03), they nevertheless indicated that they
take teaching evaluations seriously (3.90). Well over
half reported that they spend more than 5 minutes completing
the form that consists of three global items. Most
agreed that the results of student evaluations should be
published for students to use in selecting courses and instructors. Students
were unconvinced that student evaluations matter in the overall
evaluation of faculty (3.22) and unsure whether evaluation
of teaching results in improvement (3.62). These views
were reinforced by numerous comments. When asked how
the current student evaluation form should be revised, students
suggested that there should be more items and more specific
items. Additional items most frequently suggested related
to how the instructor relates to students, whether the instructor
communicates effectively, the availability of the instructor
outside of class, and the appropriateness and fairness of
evaluation/grading.
The results of the study can be used to improve procedures
for student evaluation of teaching. Along with findings
from other data sources used in the self-study, the results
provide a basis for using evaluation of teaching to improve
teaching and to recognize and reward effective teaching more
appropriately. The self-study model can be adapted
by other institutions with similar goals.
4.
COMPARISON OF FAT FREE AND REGULAR POTATO CHIPS:
GASTROINTESTINAL SYMPTOMS IN FEMALE COLLEGE STUDENTS
J. Kandiah and E. Wendt, Ball State University
Purpose. Olestra (Olean), a non-absorbable,
calorie-free fat substitute approved by the Food and Drug
Administration in 1996 has been used in snack foods such
as potato chips, crackers and tortilla chips. Products sold
as Olean bear an information label stating that olestra may
cause abdominal cramping and loose stools. Therefore, the
purpose of this study was to compare gastrointestinal (GI)
symptoms in female college students consuming fat free and
regular potato chips.
Procedures. Seventy-five, 18-21 year-old healthy
female college student volunteers from a metropolitan Mid-Western
university successfully completed this research. Eighteen-to-twenty-one-year-old
females were used because a) this specific age group had
never been used for Olestra studies; and b) of media and
social pressure, weight issues are often times a bigger problem
for young females than males.
After screening and explanation of the study protocol which
included identification of abnormal digestive problems all
participants were randomly given, monitored and ate a 2.5
ounce bag of either regular or olestra potato chips (had
20.2 g of olestra) within one half hour. Subjects also completed
a gastrointestinal distress survey within 48 hours after
testing. The following week, the same procedures were repeated,
except this time participants were offered 2.5 ounces of (either
regular or olestra) potato chips which they had not eaten
the previous week. Throughout the study, subjects were unaware
of the type of potato chips they received. Chi-square was
used to compare the number of symptoms developed by the subjects
after consumption of olestra and regular potato chips.
Results. Prior to the start of the study, with
the exception of 2 subjects (n=73) who did not indicate the
frequency of bowel movement (BM), 52 (71.2%) subjects had
BM 1-2 times/day, 5 (6.8%) had 1-2 BM/week, and 16 (22%)
of the subjects had 3 or more BM/week. After 48 hours of
consumption of regular potato chips, 85.3% (n=64) of the
subjects had no digestive distress. However, 14.7% (n=11)
reported having a total of 17 GI symptoms. Symptoms of the
11 subjects ranged from diarrhea (2.7%), loose stools (6.7%),
bloating/gas (6.7%), and stomach ache/abdominal cramping
(9.3%). After 48 hours of olestra chip consumption, 90.7%
(n=68) reported having no symptoms. However, only 7 (9.3%)
subjects experienced a total of 10 GI symptoms. Gastrointestinal
symptoms reported by the 7 subjects were loose stools (4.3%),
bloating/gas (4.3%), stomach ache/abdominal cramping (4.3%)
and diarrhea (1.3%). Although the number of subjects who
had GI symptoms was higher (n=11) after consuming regular
potato chips this was found not to be statistically significant.
Implications. These findings suggest that increased
occurrence of gastrointestinal symptoms was not prevalent
in this population (18-21 years) when they ate olestra potato
chips. Future implications include: 1) incorporation of male
and female college student and a larger sample size; 2) effectiveness
of olestra potato chips as part of an efficient weigh-loss
or weight-control regimen; and 3) investigation of college
students low-fat or fat-free snacking habits.
5.
APPLICATION OF UNIVERSAL AND LIGHTING DESIGN
Kenneth R. Tremblay, Jr., Chia-rung Lin, Li-Lin Candy
Yang, and Nancy H. Drennen,
Colorado State University
Purpose. Two crucial aspects of interior design
practice are universal and lighting design. Universal design
is a philosophy in which the goal is to optimize the usability
of products and environments by acknowledging dynamic human
functional needs that change throughout the lifespan. This
philosophy goes beyond minimal accessibility standards specified
by the Americans with Disabilities Act. The seven principles
forming the basis of universal design are equitable use,
flexibility in use, simple and intuitive use, perceptible
information, tolerance for error, low physical effort, and
size and space for approach and use. The design element of
lighting conveys what one sees into tangible images and it
enriches one€'s senses of built environments. Interior designers
are typically involved with lighting design in their projects,
often collaborating with other professionals. Lighting design
refers to the process of creating a solution for the safety,
productivity, and aesthetic quality of spaces. There exist
a number of factors that affect lighting design, most importantly
being the different functions of spaces. Thus, it is often
recommended that interior designers consider lighting in
the earliest stage of the design process, and that clients
and other professionals be consulted to ensure that lighting
systems meet users' needs. The purpose of this paper is to
investigate interior designers application of the seven universal
design principles in their own design work and to examine
the stages of the design process in which interior designers
make recommendations about lighting.
Procedures. In the Fall of 1999 a questionnaire
was mailed to all Colorado members of the American Society
of Interior Designers. There were 366 interior designers
who met this designation. After two postcard follow-ups and
a replacement questionnaire follow-up, completed questionnaires
were obtained from 163 persons. After accounting for
undelivered questionnaires and sample members who were no
longer working in the field, the 163 respondents represented
a 51% response rate. As part of the survey, the following
question was asked: To what extent do you use the seven universal
design principles in your own design work? The seven principles
were then listed with five Likert type response categories
ranging from never (coded as 1) to always (coded as 5). An
additional question was: Generally, in what stage of the
design process do you decide on the lighting system? Respondents
were requested to select only one answer from the following
stages: programming, schematic design, design development,
contract documents, bidding, construction, and post construction.
Respondents were also asked: Referring to lighting design,
who do you usually work with that affects your lighting considerations? Respondents
were able to circle as many response categories as they desired:
lighting designer, lighting engineer, architect, facility
manager, client, and other.
Findings. Results from the survey revealed that
a majority of respondents used four of the principles of
universal design in their own design work. When the frequently
and always responses are added, the following order appears:
size and space for approach and use (68.6%), flexibility
in use (58.8%), simple and intuitive use (57.4%), and low
physical effort (51.1%). The three principles of equitable
use (49.7%), perceptible information (46.4%), and tolerance
for error (42.5%) were not used by a majority of respondents.
Mean scores ranged from a high of 3.88 to a low of 3.23,
while standard deviations ranged from 1.09 to .99. Responses
to the lighting questions showed that 54.1% of respondents
made lighting decisions in the design development stage,
followed in order by 26.1% in the schematic design and 12.7%
in the programming stages. Stages not frequently mentioned
were contract documents (2.5%), construction (2.5%), and
bidding (1.9%). Although many lighting experts recommend
that lighting systems may be altered in the post construction
stage, none of the respondents made their lighting recommendations
during this stage. Results also revealed that 72.4% of respondents
worked with clients, followed by architects (44.2%) and lighting
designers (34.5%). Other responses were lighting engineers
(24.4%), facility managers (12.8%), and others (15.4%). A
mean score of 1.97 indicated that respondents collaborated
with approximately two persons in making lighting design
decisions.
Implications. Universal and lighting design
have become increasingly important to interior designers,
and will become even more so as an aging American population
requires lighting and space arrangement modifications. According
to the results of a statewide survey of ASID members, a majority
of interior designers were using the universal design principles
in their own design work. Most lighting decisions were made
in the early-middle design stages, with few made after the
design development stage. Respondents also typically worked
with two others in reaching lighting decisions, primarily
the client and either architects or lighting designers. Based
on survey results, it appears that interior designers should
further their application of universal design and broaden
their use of other professionals while considering lighting
in the earliest stage of the design process.
6.
THE IMPACT OF PERCEIVED POWER, ATTRACTION, AND ATTACHMENT
STYLE ON
THE BREAKUPS OF COMMITTED PREMARITAL RELATIONSHIPS
Jana L. Pendleton, CFCS, Maribeth C. Clarke, CFCS,
Brigham Young University
The breakup of a committed premarital relationship can be
as detrimental for those involved as an actual divorce would
be. Understanding the nature of committed premarital
relationships may help family professionals to predict and
understand the variables that contribute to unsuccessful
marriages. Power and Attraction (e.g. social rewards)
have been shown to significantly impact interpersonal relationships. For
example, if one person is considered to be more attractive
than the other, she or he is likely to retain more power
in their relationship (Peplau, 1984). Individuals gain
a sense of attachment to their primary caregiver as a young
child, and the nature of that relationship will influence
the individual's personal relationships in the future (Hazen
and Shaver, 1987). The purpose of the research study
was to determine the role that perceived power, attraction,
and attachment style may have played within the committed
relationship's dissolution.
A longitudinal study of the RELATE participants
has shown that some of these couples have since broken up. A
questionnaire was sent to these individuals (n=80, 40 couples)
which explored questions concerning the impact of attachment
theory, perceived power, and attraction on the breakup of
these committed relationships. Multiple regression
analysis was used to determine how much power, attraction,
and attachment style could explain the amount and frequency
of problems within these broken relationships.
Individuals with an avoidant attachment style retain more
power within interpersonal relationships. They are
less invested and therefore initiate the breakup of a committed
relationship. Individuals with a preoccupied attachment
style are more dependent on their partner and the relationship
and thus willing to forfeit their power.
Understanding the nature of premarital breakups and the factors
that will contribute to them will help in meeting the needs
of individuals who find them in this particular situation. The
distribution of power and attraction will most likely influence
even the most intimate relationships as well as individuals'
lives (Felmlee, 1994). The implications of attachment
theory being able to explain breakups of committed premarital
relationships is exciting in that it is an area that could
be examined prior to long-term commitment. It is comforting
for those who have already been through a breakup of a committed
relationship so that they may feel less at fault and be able
to see the same signs in future relationships. Also,
once becoming aware of one's weaknesses and working to overcome
them, it could help precipitate some self-defeating behaviors.
Feeney, J. A. (1999). Adult romantic attachment and
couple relationships. In J. Cassidy and P. R. Shaver (Eds.), Handbook
of attachment:Theory, research, and clinical applications (pp. 355-377). New
York: Guilford Press.
Hazen, C., and Shaver, P. R. (1987). Romantic love
conceptualized as an attachment process. Journal of Personality and
Social Psychology, 52, 511-524.
Peplau, A. (1984). Power in dating relationships. In
J. Freeman (Ed.), Women:A feminist perspective (pp. 121-137). Palo Alto:
Mayfield.
7.
CHILDHOOD FINANCIAL INFLUENCES AND PERSONAL FINANCE BEHAVIORS
Barbara O'Neill and Patricia Q. Brennan, Rutgers University;
Jing Xiao and Claudia Kerbel,
University of Rhode Island; Barbara Bristow, Cornell University
Purpose. This study investigated the effect
of childhood financial influences upon personal finance behaviors. A
sample of 520 MONEY 2000" program participants was surveyed. Over
three-quarters (76.6%) were female, 55% were married, and
83.5% were white. Over half of the sample earned
more than $45,000 (54.8%) and had a four-year college education
or higher (53.7%). Respondents were asked the following open-ended
question: During your growing up years, who or what had the
greatest influence on your personal financial knowledge and
behavior? They were also asked to indicate the extent to
which they were encouraged to develop a savings habit during
their growing up years and actions or planned action, if
any, with respect to 13 specific financial behaviors.
Findings. Respondents reported the greatest
influence on their finances as follows: parents or guardians
(46.9%), mother (10.4%), school saving/banking program (9%),
employment-related (e.g., a job) responses (7.7%), other
factors such as life experiences, financial media, friends,
and living through the depression (7.5%), father (7.3%),
no response (6.2%), no one (5.6%), other relatives and family
members (5.4%), and teachers (1.9%). The total percentage
exceeds 100% due to multiple responses. Respondents
perceived the extent of encouragement to save during their
childhood as: all of the time (20.3%), most of the time (23%),
occasionally (25.9%), almost never (18.6%), and not at all
(12.2%).
Chi-square tests were conducted with childhood influence
variables against behavior change variables. Childhood influence
variables had little association with later behavior changes
at the 5% level of significance. No effect of employment
or parents on any of the behavior change variables was found. One
significant relationship was found for school saving and
banking programs. Respondents who reported that school
programs had the greatest influence on their personal financial
knowledge and behavior were more likely to report behavior
changes in setting up and using a spending plan (c²=6.353,
df=2, p=.042). However, respondents who reported teachers
as the greatest influence were less likely to report paying
off consumer debts (c²=18.448, df=2, p=.001). Other
relatives (c²=7.177, df=2, p=.028) or other factors
were cited as the greatest influence by respondents who were
more likely to report keeping good financial records, but
less likely to change their behaviors in setting financial
goals (c²=10.702, df=2, p=.005), increasing income
(c²=7.833, df=2, p=.020), talking with family
members about financial goals (c²=11.132, df=2,
p=.004), and reducing spending on household expenses (c²=18.259,
df=2, p=.001). Respondents who reported nobody as their greatest
influence or gave no response were less likely to report
putting some money into investments (c²=10.894,
df=2, p=.004), keeping good financial records (c²=6.232,
df=2, p=.044), reducing spending on household expenses (c²=6.227,
df=2, p=.044), and making much progress in debt reduction
(c²=10.465, df=3, p=.015).
Chi-square analysis was also done for the question about
the extent to which respondents perceived that they were
encouraged to develop a savings habit and self-reported financial
behavior variables. Results indicated that a savings
habit developed in childhood had some association with several
behavioral variables. Respondents who checked all of
the time or most of the time regarding encouragement to save
were more likely to report paying off consumer debt (c²=16.7050,
df=8, p=.033). These results are borne out by frequencies
as well: 58.7% of respondents who checked all the time and
47.8% of those who checked most of the time reported that
they that they have no problem in paying off consumer debts,
compared to 36.9%, 36.3%, and 37.7% for those who checked
occasionally, almost never, and ot at all, respectively. The
same patterns were also found for the self-reported behaviors
save some money from each paycheck on a regular basis (c²=28.1677,
df=8, p=.0004), put some money into investments (c²=16.292,
df=8, p=.0384), and build and maintain an emergency fund
(c²=58.235, df=8, p=.0001).
Implications. This study found that parents
are perceived to be the primary influence on personal finance
knowledge and behavior. Information should, therefore,
be provided to parents to assist them as teachers and role
models. This study also found a positive effect of
school saving and banking programs on subsequent use of spending
plans. Interestingly, respondents who reported no specific
influence on their financial behavior were less likely to
report specific recommended behaviors. In other words,
having an influence of any kind (e.g., parent, school, job)
on financial knowledge and behavior appears to produce beneficial
results. This finding suggests a multifaceted approach
to financial literacy. Another interesting finding
is that respondents who perceived themselves as being encouraged
to develop a savings habit were clearly more likely to report
saving regularly, investing, building an emergency fund,
and reducing debt. This, again, provides a strong argument
for early encouragement of savings. Like many positive
lifestyle habits, practice and an early start can result
in significant benefits over time.
8. RETAILERS' PERCEPTIONS OF APPAREL AND
HOME FURNISHINGS VENDORS
Lynn Brandon, Dee Knight, and Christy Crutsinger, University
of North Texas
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to
examine the satisfaction levels of retailers regarding the
products, policies and service they receive from vendors.
Procedures. A self-administered questionnaire
was mailed to apparel (n=500) and home furnishings (n=500)
retailers randomly selected from individuals attending a
major southwest market. Retailer's satisfaction with
vendors' services was measured using a 16-item modified version
of Ruekert and Churchill's (1984) scale. Participants
indicated their levels of satisfaction on a 5-point Likert
type scale (1=not satisfied; 5=very satisfied). A
modified version of Narver and Slater's (1990) scale was
used to measure retailers' customer orientation. Retailers
indicated the extent to which their stores engage in customer-oriented
activities (e.g., customer satisfaction surveys) on a 5-point
Likert type scale (1=never; 5=always). One-way
ANOVAs determined differences between retailers' satisfaction,
customer orientation, and demographic variables.
Findings. Apparel retailers (N=162)
constituted 53.1% of the sample and 46.9% were home furnishings
retailers. The majority of participants were owners
(80.5%) of independent stores (90.3%). Those who attended
market three or more times per year (63.3%) were identified
as frequent buyers. Infrequent buyers (33.5%) were
those attending market fewer than three times per year. Parallel
tests on the 16 items revealed four dimensions (financial
outcomes, social interaction, order fulfillment, promotional
support) similar to Ruekert and Churchill's (1984) findings.
Retailers (n=77) scoring below the mean were identified
as having low customer orientation (M=1.79), and retailers
(n=61) scoring above the mean were identified as having
moderate customer orientation (M=2.92). Retailers
who frequently attended markets were less satisfied with promotional
support [F=(1,141)=4.467, p<.05] and financial
outcomes [F=(1,149)=7.573, p<.05] than those
who attended markets infrequently. Retailers
with moderate customer orientation were less satisfied with social
interaction [F=1, 132)=F=3.639, p<.05], promotional
support [F=(1,126)=14.533, p<.05] and financial
outcomes [F=(1,32)=5.992, p<.05] than
were retailers with low customer orientation.
Implications. Retailers were moderately satisfied
with the four dimensions of vendor services. However, retailers
who were moderately customer oriented and attended market
frequently were less satisfied with promotional support and
financial outcomes than those with low customer orientation
and infrequent market attendance. Vendors may satisfy
more demanding retailers with a variety of improvements. Initiating
or increasing awareness of programs including cooperative
advertising and off-price promotions may improve retailers'
satisfaction. In addition, such efforts may result
in more profitable and satisfactory channel member relationships.
References.
Narver, J. C., and Slater, S. F. (1990). The
effect of market orientation on business profitability. Journal
of Marketing, 54, 20-35.
Ruekert, R. W., and Churchill, G. A. (1984). Reliability
and validity of alternative measures of channel member satisfaction. Journal
of Marketing Research, 21(May), pp. 226-33.
9.
IMPACT OF CONSUMPTION EXPERIENCES ON CLOTHING PURCHASE
ATTITUDES:
A CROSS-NATIONAL STUDY
Jessie H. Chen-Yu and Keum-Hee Hong, Virginia Tech
and Silla University
The purpose of the study was to investigate the impact of
consumption experiences on consumers€' attitudes toward clothing
purchase. The similarities and differences between consumers
in the United States (US) and South Korea (SK) were examined.
Consumers' attitudes toward a brand and store are often influenced
by their consumption experience with the product. Consumers
who enjoy the use of the product are likely to develop favorable
attitudes toward the brand and store. Attitudes play a major
role in shaping consumer behavior. An understanding of how
consumption experiences influence consumers' clothing purchase
attitudes can assist marketers to identify factors that enhance
consumers' favorable attitudes.
Two hundred and forty participants, 120 in the US and 120
in SK, were recruited. Two scenarios were used to simulate
consumers' consumption experiences. Scenario 1 described
a condition in which consumers purchased a low-priced garment.
A warning that possible shrinkage and pilling problems may
occur was given on the label of the product. After the garment
had been worn and washed five times, the garment showed noticeable
shrinkage and pilling. Scenario 2 described a condition in
which consumers purchased a high-priced garment. A guarantee
of good after-wash performance was given on the label. After
the garment had been worn and washed five times, the appearance
of the garment showed no change. A questionnaire was developed
to measure participants€' clothing purchase attitudes before
and after their experience in the scenario.
The factor analysis revealed four factors of clothing purchase
attitudes. They were labeled as quality consciousness, information
consciousness, economic consciousness and product interest/
involvement. After experiencing the condition in Scenario,
the paired t-tests showed that US participants' product
interest/involvement had decreased. SK participants did not
change their product interest/involvement; instead, their
information consciousness had increased. These results suggest
that for the US market, offering a low price without good
product performance would not benefit the company. Poor product
performance would lead to negative attitudes toward the brand
and/or the store. When selling low-price, moderate quality
products in SK, marketers should provide truthful product
performance information. This practice would not create negative
influence on the business. On the contrary, accurate information
may increase consumers' confidence in the company.
oth US and SK participants' quality consciousness had increased
after they experienced the condition of Scenario 2. In future
purchases, participants would buy more clothing of high quality
and use price as a cue to predict the performance of the
product. In addition to quality consciousness, SK participants'
information consciousness also had increased. These results
suggest that providing information on labels and hangtags
was important for the SK market. This was an effective way
to promote products because this information is provided
at the moment when consumers were making their final purchase
decision. Results also showed that after experiencing this
scenario, US participants' product interest/involvement had
increased. This result suggests that providing a higher-priced
product with good performance may be a way to increase US
consumers' brand/store involvement and loyalty.
10.
ADOPTION OF THE INTERNET FOR APPAREL SHOPPING BY COLLEGE
STUDENTS
Cynthia R. Easterling and Dolly Loyd, The University
of Southern Mississippi
Retailers have shown an increasing interest in catering
to the needs, wants, and desires of young adult consumers
who have become a powerful social and economic force, which also
makes them a critically important market segment for consumer
products and services. Young adults represent a large
percentage of the American population and have been identified
as having a strong buying power. Because America's
youth seem comfortable with technology, a number of retailers
have targeted young consumers via websites for apparel shopping.
Although traditional college-age students (approximately
18 to 25 years of age) often use the Internet as a classroom
tool, little is known about the apparel shopping habits with
the Internet by this consumer group. The purpose of
the study was to quantify adoption of the Internet by college
students for apparel shopping.
The study involved a self-administered questionnaire designed
to secure information about the shopping habits of traditional
college-age students for apparel goods on the Internet. The
study sample consisted of 192 college students at a regional
university in the Southeastern United States. Participation
was voluntary and took place during regular class times in
a random selection of general elective classes in December,
2000. Frequency and percentage distributions were used
to analyze the basic information and chi-square analysis
was computed.
Most of the students held part-time jobs and approximately
one-half of the sample had over $100 of discretionary income
each month. The participants in the study were female
(n=134) and males (n=58) ranging in age from 18 to 25. The
students represented all college classifications and over
10 different major areas of study. No matter where the purchases
were made, virtually all of the students indicated that they
select and buy their own apparel. While most of the
students (72%) had used the Internet to observe fashion trends
and merchandise, only 56 percent of the students actually
purchased goods online. Most of the students who purchased
apparel online completed the transactions from home based
computers and used personal credit cards for the purchases. Almost
all of the purchases were made from websites of well-known
retail stores and apparel manufacturers, and the most
popular selections included clothing, shoes, and cosmetics. The
lack of credit card security and the inability to see the
merchandise were frequently listed by the participants as
major problems associated with online shopping.
A significant relationship was found between discretionary
income groups: Students with more discretionary income
were more likely to purchase online apparel goods. No
differences were found between Internet purchasing habits
and such factors as gender, classification and age.
Understanding the spending habits and purchasing practices
of young consumers provides marketers with information that
can be used to sell services and products. By understanding
the needs of young consumers, family and consumer science
educators are better positioned to prepare fashion merchandising
students for successful retailing careers. Educators
should include Internet assignments in their courses to provide
a variety of opportunities for students.
11.
INFLUENCE OF LIFESTYLE ORIENTATION ON INFORMATION SEARCH,
EVALUATION AND PURCHASE OF CASUAL APPAREL AND HOME FURNISHINGS
PRODUCTS
Judith C. Forney and Lynn Brandon, University of North
Texas
This study investigated female consumers' information search,
evaluation and purchase of casual apparel and home furnishings
by their casual or formal lifestyles. The trend of
casual expression in apparel and the home suggested the study's
situational context.
Female consumers (N=196) in a southwest state responded
to a self-administered questionnaire. A two-column
format (casual apparel/home furnishings) assessed respondent's
frequency of use during the past year by a 7-point Likert-type
scale (range: 7=high to 1=low) for 11 information
sources and 14 purchase sources, and importance (range: 7=high to
1=low) for 23 evaluative criteria. Casual/formal lifestyles
were measured by a 7-point semantic differential (1=casual,
7=formal) for six descriptors of apparel and the home. A
factor analysis revealed lifestyle dimensions for apparel
and home with reliabilities over .88. Lifestyle was
calculated as average summed scores for both apparel and
home; scores between 1 and 3.5 were casual and scores between
3.6 and 7 were formal. Analyses included descriptive
statistics and ANOVAs.
Retail store displays, magazines, and newspapers had the
highest overall mean scores, regardless of product category
or lifestyle. Women with formal lifestyles had significantly
higher frequency of use of newspapers and retail displays
when purchasing casual apparel and home furnishings.
Evaluative criteria including color, style, price, comfort,
durability, fit, fabric quality, construction quality, product
quality, coordination, appropriateness of purpose, and beauty
all received very high importance ratings. Women with
formal lifestyles gave significantly higher ratings to store
image, fabric quality, prestigious image of manufacturer,
hangtag information, and construction detail for apparel. They
also gave higher ratings for brand name labels, store image,
prestigious image of manufacturer, hangtag information, beauty,
and private labels for home furnishings.
Department stores and discount department stores had the
highest frequency of use, regardless of lifestyle or product. Women
with a formal lifestyle shopped more at department stores
for casual apparel, and at small independent specialty, department,
mass merchandiser, and large chain stores for casual home
furnishings.
In this study, women exhibited different decision-making
processes based on their lifestyle. Women with formal
lifestyles had a higher frequency of use for several information
and purchase sources, and they placed higher importance on
evaluative criteria when purchasing in two casual product
categories. Identifying lifestyle preferences may be
a useful and important component when assisting consumers
with product decisions. Also, by understanding the
impact of lifestyle on consumer decisions, retailers can
better meet consumer needs. Retailers need to offer
products that have the desired attributes and use the market
sources that reflect consumer purchase decisions.
12.
PRESERVING AND INDEXING TEXTILES FROM THE FAG EL GAMOUS
CEMETERY IN
FAYUM, EGYPT, TO FACILITATE THEIR COMPARISON WITH KNOWN
COPTIC TEXTILES
Rachel P. Hiatt, Maribeth C. Clarke, CFCS, Marvin
C. J. Kuchar, Mary H. Farahnakian, Brigham Young University
Ongoing analysis of the textiles excavated from the Fag
el Gamous Cemetery in Egypt has led researchers to investigate
the culture of the people buried there. The purposes of this
specific study are to (1) establish a means to categorize,
order and preserve the textiles retrieved from Fag el Gamous,
and (2) determine a possible relationship between the Fag
el Gamous textiles and textiles from known Coptic cultures.
This research project was carried out in four phases: first,
becoming familiar with the Fag el Gamous textile collection
and known Coptic textile collections by studying samples
from each, using museum catalogs for the Coptic collections;
second, exploring, acquiring and setting up the necessary
technology for image collection, image management, data management,
and image and data retrieval; third, scanning the Fag el
Gamous textiles and creating an image database for further
textile study and preservation of the ancient textiles; and
fourth, comparing the Fag el Gamous textile collection by
the Sibley (1981) instrument and with known Coptic textile
collections to determine how the Fag el Gamous textiles differ
from Coptic textiles.
The computer technology was successfully implemented. The
high-resolution scanned images allow researchers to study
the Fag el Gamous textiles without handling them. A searchable
database containing a keyword index, text and images of all
the 1998 excavated textiles was created using ImageFinder
software.
The 1998 Fag el Gamous textiles did not contain the Coptic
attributes listed in the 1981 Sibley instrument. The comparison
of Fag el Gamous and museum Coptic textiles led to the conclusion
that although there are significant stylistic differences,
the two groups contain some similar structural elements.
The structural elements, such as fiber types and weave structures,
indicate that the same resources were available to make Fag
el Gamous and Coptic textiles. Stylistically, the Coptic
designs are more elaborate, use more colors, and include
typical Coptic motif. The Fag el Gamous designs are smaller,
have fewer colors, and meticulous workmanship. There does
appear to be some relationship between the Fag el Gamous
textiles and textiles from known Coptic collections, even
though the 1998 Fag el Gamous textiles are not Coptic.
Sibley, L.R. (1981). Coptic textiles at the Nelson Gallery
of Art, Kansas City: A stylistic and structural approach. (Doctoral dissertation,
University of Missouri"Columbia, 1981). Dissertation Abstracts International,
42/09-B, 3645.
13.
FURS: CONTROVERSY AND CONSERVATION
Catherine Amoroso Leslie, The Ohio State University
Purpose. Fur has been used for clothing since
prehistoric times and is an important part of costume history. Curators
of historic costume collections have special challenges with
furs such as cold storage and infestation (Serafino, 1988). Furs
also present another challenge "they are in the middle of
a social debate. Although anti-fur activism took hold in
the early 1960s, activists became more visible and confrontational
in the late 1980s. These actions caused some businesses
to change their practices. Spiegel dropped fur from
its catalogs and Wheel of Fortune ceased giving fur coats
as prizes (Lynden, 1989). Activism also affected consumer
attitudes. Vryza and Hines (1994) found that members
of anti-fur organizations considered furs to be less fashionable
than nonmembers. Moreover, fur owners thought the use
of fur in apparel was more moral than those who did not own
garments made of fur. If personal attitudes influenced
views of furs, could they influence how furs were being stored
and exhibited in collections? The research purpose
was to examine the types and kinds of furs in historic costume
collections, how they were stored and exhibited, and concerns
about the public's response to fur from the curators' perspective. Exploring
fur in collections can offer insights to how museums face
issues of special storage and public sentiment.
Procedures. The sample was individuals who included
the word, curator in their listing in The Costume Society
of America 2000 Membership Directory. Themes from four
open-ended interviews with selected curators were used to
produce a multiple choice and open-ended questionnaire. The
questionnaire was distributed to 65 curators by email and
fax; 31 instruments were completed for a response rate of
48 percent.
Findings and Implications. Ninety-two percent
of the collections in the sample had fur garments and only
four percent had cold storage. Fifty-five percent of
the curators had exhibited fur garments of some kind and
only one reported an incident in which a visitor had an overt
negative reaction; however, 52% expressed concerns about
including fur in future exhibitions. Most curators
stated that the current political climate did not affect
the handling of fur garments in their collections, but responses
to exhibition plans and concerns expressed indicate some
consideration to these issues. There is sufficient
literature to indicate that fur garments stored above 45
degrees will deteriorate. The virtual absence of cold
storage in this sample indicates there will be a decline
in extant fur garments in the future. Furthermore,
withholding furs from public view may be contrary to the
mission of museums. Although more research is required
to delve into these issues, this study can offer some insights. In
dealing with fur curators have the challenges of adequate
storage and public sentiment. As clothing fashions
come and go, so do currently expressed opinions. When
the climate of fur activism fades away, will there be any
furs left in our collections?
References.
Lynden, P. (1989, November). The
fur dilemma. Connoisseur, 219 (934), 112-120.
Serafino, G. (1988, Fall). Fur storage at the Provincial
Museum of Alberta. Textile Conservation Newsletter (Canada), 15, 10-11.
Vryza, M., and Hines, J. D. (1994). The use of fur
for apparel: An attitudinal study. Journal of Family and Consumer Sciences.
86 (3), 45-50.
14.
FASHION GROUPS AND FASHION PROBLEM RECOGNITION STYLE
Cathryn M. Studak and Jane E. Workman, Southern Illinois
University
Purpose . The consumer decision-making process
has five distinct segments: problem recognition, information
search, alternative evaluation, purchase decision, and post-purchase
evaluation. The purpose of this study is to focus on
the first segment, problem recognition, to examine if differences
exist among four consumer groups: fashion opinion leaders,
fashion innovators, innovative communicators, and fashion
followers. Consistently, fashion change agents-fashion innovators,
fashion opinion leaders, and innovative communicators-have
been found to make purchasing decisions differently from
fashion followers. The way a consumer recognizes a problem
and becomes motivated to solve the problem will influence
the remainder of the decision-making process. Problem
recognition reflects a difference between the consumer's
ideal state and actual state: a discrepancy exists between
what consumers want a situation to be like and what a situation
is really like (Belch and Belch, 1993). An actual state
reflects a utilitarian or need-based approach whereas an
ideal state reflects a psychological or want-based approach
to product selection.
Procedures. University students (n=113; 49 males;
64 females) completed Hirschman and Adcock's (1987) Measure
of Fashion Innovativeness and Opinion Leadership, Bruner's
(1987) Fashion Problem Recognition Style scale (high scores
indicate an actual state; low scores indicate an ideal state),
and demographic information. Members of the four fashion
groups were determined using Hirschman and Adcock's procedure. Data
were analyzed using descriptive statistics and ANOVA.
Findings. ANOVA with fashion group as the independent
variable and scores on the Fashion Problem Recognition Scale
as the dependent variable revealed main effects for fashion
group, F (4,105)=14.62 and sex, F (1,105)=21.25, p<.01. Fashion
followers scored higher on the Scale than innovators, opinion
leaders or innovative communicators. Males scored higher
on the scale than females.
Implications. Fashion followers, regardless
of gender, and males, regardless of fashion group, reflected
a utilitarian approach to problem recognition. Collectively,
the fashion change agents reflected a psychological approach
to problem recognition. The basic premise behind problem
recognition style, actual vs. ideal, was validated.
References.
Belch, George E., and Belch, Michael
A. (1993). Introduction to advertising and
promotion: An integrated marketing communications perspective
(2nd ed.). Irwin: Homewood, IL.
Bruner, G.C. (1987). Problem recognition styles: Conceptualization
and scale development. Journal of Midwest Marketing, 2(1), 78-86.
Hirschman, E., and Adcock, W. (1987). An examination of innovative
communicators, opinion leaders, and innovators for men's fashion apparel.
In H. Keith Hunt (ed.), Advances in consumer research (pp.303-314).
Ann Arbor, MI: Association for Consumer Research.
15.
BIODEGRADATION ASSESSMENT OF COTTON, RAYON AND TENCEL
FABRICS
Mary Warnock, Duane Wolf and Karon Davis, University
of Arkansas
Purpose. The purpose of the project was to
conduct a field study to determine the biodegradation rates
of cotton, rayon and Tencel fabrics buried in an aerobic
soil. The influence of fabric decomposition on tensile
strength, flex abrasion, and tearing strength was evaluated.
Procedure. Cotton, rayon and Tencel fabrics
were cut into 25x25-cm units and placed in tulle having 1x2-mm
mesh openings. The enclosed fabric samples were buried
in a Captina silt loam soil. The herbicide Roundup
was used to eliminate vegetation in the plot. Fabric
specimens were removed from the soil following 14, 28, 42,
77 and 112 days of burial. Fabric decomposition was
reported as the mean quantity of dry, ash-free fabric remaining
over time. The first order kinetics model was used
to describe fabric biodegradation. Tensile strength,
tearing strength and flex abrasion tests were performed following
each burial period. ANOVA analyses followed by Fisher€'s
LSD test were used for statistical purposes.
Findings. The amount of fabric remaining over
time demonstrated rapid biodegradation of cotton and rayon
with Tencel being more resistant to decomposition. With
high soil temperatures of approximately 30 C and adequate
soil moisture during the initial 55 days of the field study,
rapid cellulose biodegradation would be expected.
Plots of the natural logarithm of fabric remaining versus
time showed that fabric biodegradation could be described
by first-order kinetics. The first-order rate constants
(k) were significantly different and followed the decreasing
order of rayon>cotton>Tencel. The calculated
half-life values were 8, 17 and 87 days for rayon, cotton
and Tencel, respectively. The ease of biodegradation
was inversely related to the amount of crystalline cellulose
in the fabric. As the quantity of amorphous cellulose
in the fabric increased and the length of the polymer chains
decreased, availability of the cellulose substrate for microbial
use increased which resulted in more rapid biodegradation
of the fabric.
th regard to warp and filling yarn directions, all fabric
types decreased in tensile strength, tearing strength, and
resistance to flex abrasion throughout the study. Rayon
and cotton specimens lost>95% of their tensile strength
capacity following 14 days of burial and were completely
biodegraded by the end of 28 days. The Tencel specimens
also decreased in tensile strength with>60% strength loss
occurring after 14 days of burial. Overall, rayon exhibited
the least resistance to flex abrasion while Tencel showed
the greatest resistance. With respect to tearing strength,
all test specimens, irrespective of fabric type, continued
to lose>50% of their strength capacity with each test
period. At the end of 42 days, only the Tencel specimens
remained for analyses.
Implications. Soil burial is an effective method
to determine biodegradation properties of textiles. A
real life situation was created by this field study whereby
biodegradable predictions could be assessed. This basic
biodegradability information should encourage textile manufacturers
to produce environmental friendly goods and support waste
management policy-makers.
16.
OWNERSHIP AND VISIBILITY OF ALCOHOL PROMOTIONAL CLOTHING
ITEMS
Jane E. Workman, Naomi Arseneau, Chandra Ewell, Kristen
Young, Southern Illinois University
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to examine
ownership and visibility of alcohol promotional clothing
items (APCIs) and the association between APCI ownership
and alcohol use. Alcohol use is a major public health problem
with consequences that include risky behavior, physical injuries,
and even death. Exposure to alcohol advertising is positively
correlated with adolescents' alcohol use (Kohn and Smart,
1987). Promotional tactics of alcohol companies such as giving
away t-shirts advertising alcohol often target adolescent
consumers which raises a question: Is ownership of alcohol
promotional clothing items related to alcohol use?
Procedures. Participants were university students
(120 males; 106 females) who completed a questionnaire about
demographics, alcohol use, ownership and visibility of alcohol
promotional clothing items. Items from The American Drug
and Alcohol Survey (RMBSI, 1994) and Sargent et al.'s (1997)
survey of cigarette promotional items were adapted for use
in this study.
Findings. Participants ranged in age from 18 to 51
(m=21.71); 53.3% were under 21; 219 (96.5%) had tried drinking
alcohol. Nearly 40% of participants owned an APCI and 80%
reported their friends owned APCIs. APCI ownership did not
vary by sex or age group (under 21 v. 21 and older). APCIs
included t-shirts, hats, jackets, shorts, and sweatshirts
with t-shirts and hats most common items. There were 40 different
alcohol brand names on the APCIs with Budweiser the most
common. Only 3.1% of participants reported wearing an APCI
the day of the survey, but 52.4% reported seeing an APCI
on campus that day. Chi square tests comparing alcohol use
of students who owned APCIs with those who did not revealed
significant differences (p<.000): those who owned APCIs
were more likely to respond "more than 100" about
how many drinks they had in their whole life; more likely
to respond "yes" to whether they would drink alcohol
in the next two months; to drink at least once a week; and
to indicate they would drink again.
Implications. Alcohol promotional clothing items were
prevalent and highly visible in the social environment of
these university students with 17 students seeing an APCI
for each one who wore an APCI. A relationship between ownership
of APCIs and drinking was evidenced by extent of alcohol
use over a participants' lifetime, likelihood of drinking
in the next two months, likelihood of drinking once a week,
and intent to drink in the future. Students send a powerful
pro-drinking message to their peers by wearing APCIs. Persistent
exposure to this message leaves students vulnerable to adopting
behavior detrimental to their physical and emotional health.
References.
Kohn, P., and Smart, R. (1987). Wine, women,
suspiciousness and advertising. Journal of Studies of Alcohol, 48(2),
161-166.
RMBSI, Inc. (1994). American Drug and Alcohol Survey.
Fort Collins, CO: RMBSI, Inc.
Sargent, J., Dalton, M., Beach, M., Bernhardt, A., Pullin,
D., and Stevens, M. (1997, December). Cigarette promotional items in public
schools. Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine, 151, 1189-1196.
This research was supported by a Southern Illinois University
Undergraduate Research Award.
17.
PURCHASE MOTIVATIONS AND PRODUCE SATISFACTION OF SINGLE
WOMEN:
DO CHILDREN MAKE A DIFFERENCE?
Lynn Brandon and Judith C. Forney , University of North
Texas
Consumer purchase decisions are often influenced by demographic
characteristics, lifestyle, and product experience. Of
interest to family and consumer scientists is the influence
of having children on purchase motivations and product satisfaction. This
study examined motivations and satisfaction with casual apparel
and home furnishings by the incidence of having children.
A sample (N=198) of female consumers residing in a southwest
state completed self-administered mailed questionnaires. Only
single women with (n=77) and without children (n=61) were
included in the analysis. Most women had professional
occupations (88.4%), were Anglo (62.8%) or Hispanics (29.2%),
were between the ages of 31 and 50 (69.5%), and had household
incomes over $50,000 (71.2%). Chi-square analyses found
no significant differences between groups on these demographic
characteristics.
A two-column format (casual apparel/home furnishings) assessed
respondent's agreement using a 7-point Likert-type scale
(range: 7=high to 1=low). Responses to "When
I shop with an intent to purchase, it is because of a measured
seven motivational attributes: item do not have, replace
item no longer serviceable, updating, personal fulfillment,
and a change in income, physical condition, and lifestyle. Responses
to "After I make a purchase, I generally measured eight
satisfaction attributes: satisfaction with purchase,
display or show item, find it goes well with other items,
complain to retailer about damage, complain to retailer about
performance, complain to others, return item, and ask retailer
for alterations/modifications. Independent principle
components factor analyses with varimax rotation resulted
in two motivational factors: experiential (5 items)
and product-oriented (2 items), and the same two satisfaction
factors: complaining/retribution (5 items) and fulfillment
(3 items) for both product categories. Reliabilities
ranged from .54 to .91. All items loaded at .50 or
above. Total scale values were determined for each
motivational and satisfaction factor.
Motivational mean scores showed respondents rated product-oriented
motivations highest for both casual apparel and home furnishings,
regardless of children. Within the experiential motivation
factor, all respondents rated the need to update (wardrobe,
furnishings) highest. Satisfaction mean scores revealed
very low agreement with all items included in the complaining/restitution
factor for all respondents in both product categories. ANOVAs
revealed no significant differences between groups on any
motivational factor or satisfaction factor for either product
category.
Although children can impact family decisions regarding consumer
purchases, for this sample and for the product categories
studied, having children did not seem to make a difference. These
findings were unexpected, especially since the sample was
single women. This sample was fairly affluent with
professional careers and incomes above the national average;
these characteristics may have influenced the findings. Further
study with a larger sample and a comparison with married
women are warranted.
18.
MATURE CONSUMERS' SERVICE NEEDS:
COMPARING PERCEPTIONS OF MATURE CONSUMERS AND APPAREL RETAILERS
Beth Wuest, Southwest Texas State University
Problem. Quality customer service has been
associated with customer satisfaction which in turn, has
been related to customer loyalty and repeat patronage. Consequently,
retailers, including apparel retailers, are looking for means
of strengthening their service strategies in order to more
effectively meet the needs of their customers. However,
to develop an effective customer service strategy, a common
understanding of the importance of customer services between
the consumer and retailer is crucial.
Purpose. The focus of this study was to compare
mature consumers' perceptions of the importance of various
consumer services when purchasing apparel products with those
of the apparel retailers' perceptions. More specifically,
this study was intended to examine services considered most
and least important to mature consumers and apparel retailers
and to identify the similarities and differences in the perceptions
of the two groups.
Procedures. A descriptive and comparative survey
design was used in this study. A self-administered
questionnaire was developed and pretested. Mature apparel
consumers' and apparel retailers' perceptions of customer
services were measured with a 23-item, modified version of
Lumpkin, Greenberg and Goldstucker's (1985) Likert scale. A
total of 100 questionnaires were returned from the mature
consumer sample and deemed usable out of 456 accurate addresses,
yielding a response rate of 21.91%. A total of
99 were returned from the apparel retailers sample and deemed
usable out of 427 accurate addresses, yielding a response
rate of 24.2%. The data collected was analyzed using
descriptive and comparative statistical measures.
Findings. The scale was determined to be reliable
for measuring mature consumers' and apparel retailers' perceptions
of the importance of customer services with an reliability
alpha of 0.83. Of the 23-items in Lumpkin, Greenberg
and Goldstucker's scale, means values for the mature consumers
ranged from 4.08 to 6.82 out of a range of 1.0 to 7.0 with
1" indicating not important and 7" indicating very
important. For the apparel retailers the means values
ranged from 4.24 to 6.78. Eight of the scale items
resulted in significant differences between the two groups
at the 0.05 level. Most notable was the item ranked
most important to the mature consumers, relating to the ability
to return unsatisfactory products.
The scale items were factored into seven groups. With
factor loadings greater than 0.60, 16 of the 23 items were
included in the factors. These factors were named and
ranked by the mature consumer from most important to least
important as follows: quality assurance; shopping ease; personalized
service; credit options; physical facilities; merchandising;
and package assistance. Of these seven factors, the
importance of four were rated significantly different by
mature consumers and apparel retailers at the 0.05 level. Three
were rated significantly higher by the mature consumer: quality
assurance, shopping ease and physical facilities. Only
credit options was rated significantly higher by apparel
retailers.
Implications. This study presents a list of
customer services perceived to be most important when appealing
to needs of mature consumers. To meet the needs of
the mature apparel consumer, retail managers are encouraged
to recognize the importance that many of their customers
are placing on specific areas of customer service. Their
goal should be to recognize the true importance of their
customers€' needs and develop plans to efficiently meet or
exceed the quality of services demanded. In addition,
customers, young or old, should be able to appropriately
convey their needs to the service provider.
Reference.
Lumpkin, J., Greenberg, B., and
Goldstucker, J. (1985). Marketing needs of the
elderly: Determinant attributes and store choices. Journal
of Retailing, 61 (2), 75-105.
19.
A VALUE-ADDED APPROACH TO LEARNING
Diana Cone and Diane Phillips, Georgia Southern University
Purpose. As we enter the new millennium, educators
are challenged to provide an educational paradigm which provides
holistic, interdisciplinary experiences that parallel today's
business environment. Collaborative learning (individuals
working together toward a common goal) can help prepare students
for the workplace, promote team problem solving, improve
communication skills, encourage learning in a global context
and challenge students to become creative. The purpose
was to pilot a collaborative project that required students
from various disciplines and classes to function in a real-world
setting.
Procedures. Two family and consumer science
faculty members developed a pilot project which involved
a collaborative network between students and business professionals.
Students in three separate classes, representing five disciplines
combined their knowledge, skills, and efforts toward the
completion of one common project. The objectives
of the multifaceted project were to:
- utilize resources to maximum efficiency
in real-life problem solving situations
- identify and capitalize on individual
strengths in a team setting
- apply problem-solving skills
- demonstrate effective communication skills
- produce professional quality work by capitalizing
on the knowledge and skills
received from the entire sequence of professional courses.
Students formed multi-level teams, created a theme for an
exhibit, communicated with business officials throughout
the planning of the exhibit, created a model of their exhibit,
and developed a brochure highlighting their theme. Each
team presented their group's ideas and the most workable
and creative solution was selected for actual implementation.
Findings. Students worked collaboratively
to successfully satisfy the project requirements. Each
team member brought specialization to the group. This cross-departmental
and cross-discipline collaboration project with business
professionals proved to be both challenging and exciting. Post-project
evaluations of the pilot project completed by students and
business professionals indicated that students felt more
confident about their own strengths and applying them in
a group with members from diverse backgrounds, and that receiving
criticism and accepting others' views was a difficult aspect
of the project. The business professionals indicated
that the students exhibited a higher level of preparedness
with each session and were better able to express their ideas
and formulate questions.
Implications. This pilot project showed thatcollaborative
work can enhance the learning environment by aiding in problem
solving, fostering interdisciplinary thinking, and promoting
analytical and communicative skills of all forms. This
value-added approach to learning fosters thinking and decision
making that are necessary in today's workplace.
TOP OF PAGE
20.
EMPATHY LEVELS OF ADOLESCENTS ENROLLED IN
HIGH SCHOOL FAMILY AND CONSUMER SCIENCES
Karen L. Alexander and Jerelyn B. Schultz, University
of Kentucky and The Ohio State University
The purposes of this study were to examine empathy levels
of adolescents enrolled in FCS programs, to determine whethercognitive
and emotional empathy behaviors differed by gender, and to
determine how demographic variables influenced adolescent
empathy.
The purposeful sample (n=186) consisted of students
in FCS programs from three different communities: rural,
urban, and suburban. Females comprised 69% of the sample
and males comprised 31% of the sample. The sample was
also distributed across grades nine, ten, eleven and twelve.
Subjects were administered the Interpersonal Reactivity Index
(Davis, 1980) which measures four dimensions of empathy: empathic
concern, (r=.74); personal distress, (r=.73);
perspective taking, (r=.73); fantasy, (r=.75).
Overall means and standard deviations were generated for
each of the four subscales of the Interpersonal Reactivity
Index: Perspective Taking (M=14.64, SD=4.38);
Fantasy (M=13.21, SD=4.98); Personal Distress
(M=12.03, SD=4.41); and Empathic Concern (M=18.14, SD=4.16). The
ANOVA determined that gender was a significant contributor
to the variance between the four subscales: Perspective
Taking (F=11.61, p<.001), Fantasy (F=7.33, p<.007),
Personal Distress (F=49.62, p<.000), and
Empathic Concern (F=28.10, p<.000).
Males had lower mean scores than females. The means
and standard deviations for males were Perspective Taking
(M=13.02, SD=4.42), Fantasy (M=11.71, SD=5.46),
Personal Distress (M=8.93, SD=4.21), and Empathic
Concern (M=15.82, SD=4.33). The means
and standard deviations for females were Perspective Taking
(M=15.34, SD=4.19), Fantasy (M=13.84, SD=4.64),
Personal Distress (M=13.38, SD=3.78), and Empathic
Concern (M=19.13, SD=3.67).
Gender was used as a covariant in the multivariate analysis
of empathy. Results determined that grade level was
the only demographic variable that contributed to the variance
in the empathy subscales with a significant Wilks' Lambda
of .853 (f=2.02, p=.02). Analysis of
the grade levels showed that twelfth graders had the highest
means on three subscales: Fantasy (M=14.16, SD=5.65),
Perspective Taking (M=15.76, SD=4.17), and
Empathic Response (M=19.11, SD=4.28), and they
had the lowest score on the Personal Distress subscale (M=10.74, SD=4.00). Ninth
graders showed the highest level of personal distress (M=12.76, SD=4.88). Tenth
graders had the second highest scores on the Fantasy, Perspective
Taking, and Empathic Response subscales and the second lowest
score on the Personal Distress subscale.
Gender is an important variable with empathy. The development
and implementation of FCS curriculum content must promote
more experiences related to empathy for all students but
especially for males. Male perspectives in the curriculum
development process are critical because the majority of
FCS educators are female and would tend to develop curriculum
and instructional materials from a female perspective.
Age is also an important variable with empathy. Empathy
development is a process and FCS educators must promote its
development throughout the curriculum. Since there
is evidence from existing research of a pattern of earlier
cognitive development in adolescents, the cognitive aspects
of empathy (perspective taking, fantasy) should be the focus
of courses with early to middle adolescents. Since
the emotional aspects of empathy (empathic concern, personal
distress) tend to increase with the development of cognition,
courses serving middle to late adolescents should provide
more opportunities to develop the emotional aspects of empathy. Experiences
with planning and participating in service learning projects,
especially through FCCLA, may also increase empathy development
for all students.
21.
CHARACTERISTICS OF FAMILY AND CONSUMER SCIENCES TEACHERS
RELATED TO
ATTITUDES TOWARD USING COMPUTERS AS AN INSTRUCTIONAL MEDIUM
Sheri L. Lokken, Wanda K. Cheek, Shirley W. Hastings,
Mississippi State University,
Mississippi State University, University of Tennessee
Computer anxiety and attitude toward computers exhibited
by high school teachers can present a significant obstacle
to helping students become more technology proficient and
make teachers more reluctant to incorporate technology. The
purpose of this study was to examine relationships among
characteristics of high school family and consumer sciences
(FCS) teachers (age, education, computer experience, and
computer usage) with their attitudes toward computers (computer
anxiety, computer liking, confidence in computer skills,
and importance of computers as a learning method) prior to
technology training.
The sample consisted of 42 FCS teachers selected to participate
in a new technology-based FCS program. The Computer
Anxiety and Attitudes Toward Computers Study (Chou, 1997)
questionnaire was administered to the teachers to investigate
their attitudes toward computers prior to completing an intensive,
two-week technology training. A team of three university
faculty members collected the data and conducted the training. For
the purposes of this study, computer experience, computer
use, computer anxiety, computer liking, confidence in computer
skills, and importance of computers as a learning method
were quantified based on numerical scores assigned to participants'
responses using Chou€'s methods.
Hypotheses were: 1) Age will be positively related
to anxiety and inversely related to confidence, liking, and
importance as a learning method. 2) Education will
be inversely related to anxiety and positively related to
confidence, liking, and importance as a learning method. 3)
Computer experience will be inversely related to anxiety
and positively related to confidence, liking, and importance
as a learning method. 4) Computer use will be inversely
related to anxiety and positively related to confidence,
liking, and importance as a learning method.
Pearson correlations were run to test for relationships among
variables. Age was positively correlated with anxiety
(r=.429, p=.005) and inversely correlated with confidence
(r=-.345, p=.023). Education was positively correlated
with anxiety (r=.420, p=.006) and inversely correlated with
importance as a learning method (r=-.374, p=.015). Computer
experience was not significantly correlated with any dependent
variable, and computer use was significantly inversely correlated
with computer anxiety (r=-.326, p=.035). Findings indicate
older teachers may have more anxiety toward computers and
less confidence in using computers. In this sample,
older teachers held the highest degrees, had more computer
anxiety, and placed less value on computers as a learning
tool in the classroom. Finally, higher frequency of
computer use by teachers appears to be correlated with less
computer anxiety. These characteristics of teachers
should be taken into account by trainers in preparing technology
instruction for teachers.
Chou, T. R. (1997). The relationships among computer usage,
experience with the computer, computer anxiety, and attitudes toward computers
for secondary agricultural education teachers in the United States. Mississippi
State: Dissertation.
22.
GENDER AS A FACTOR IN COGNITIVE STYLE OF PROFESSIONALS
IN
FAMILY AND CONSUMER SCIENCE FIELDS
Barbara L. Stewart, Robert L. Fritz, and Marcella Norwood,
University of Houston
Among the challenges of preparing future professionals for
careers in Family and Consumer Sciences is the current employment
climate, which demands ever-increasing levels of analytic
skills. Family and Consumer Science educators can assist
in preparing graduates by identifying students for potential
success in specific professional areas by matching students'
talents and abilities with the demands of the workplace.
Three aspects of this opportunity were included for this
investigation. First, the personal talent and skill
area of cognitive style was selected for investigation because
it has been identified as a substantial influence on the
application of mental functioning of individuals in specific
situations. Second, gender was included to assess the
influence of gender on cognitive style. Third, professionals
representing two specific fields open to students in Family
and Consumer Science programs were examined. These
professional fields were consumer services and purchasing. Additionally,
secondary students were included in the analysis for comparison.
Methods. Intact group methodology was used to
identify and gather data from 44 professionals and 237 secondary
students. Professionals were members of the Society
of Consumer Affairs Professionals, the International Consumer
Service Association, and the National Association of Purchasing
Management.
The Group Embedded Figures Test (GEFT) is a standardized
test of cognitive style. Test scores of 0-18 indicate
subjects€' scaled position as having a field-dependent or
field-independent cognitive style. The GEFT was administered
in group settings to both the professionals and the high
school students. Data analysis included ANOVA and a
Scheffe test for statistical significance.
Findings. Of the professionals, 30 subjects
were female and 14 were male. Of the students, 150 participants
were female and 87 were male. With regard to gender,
the GEFT scores of participants were statistically different. Significant
differences (p<.05) were found for both the professional
and student groups. In each case males had scores indicating
more field-independent cognitive styles. Additionally,
the GEFT scores of professional males were significantly
more field-independent than the scores of professional women.
Implications. In all cases, mean scores of professionals
and students indicated greater field-independent cognitive
styles for men than for women. This may have implications
for career advisement and preparation of future professionals. It
is possible that assessment of gender coupled with cognitive
style could aid educators in helping students select particular
career options and in developing curricular experiences designed
to stretch or develop specific skills in students needed
to meet workplace demands.
23.
PRINCIPAL'S PERCEPTION OF FEMALE TEACHERS DRESS ON TEACHING
EFFECTIVENESS
Janie O. Kenner, Rachel A. Underwood, Sandra McClune,
Stephen F. Austin State University
Clothing is more than physical appearance. It supports a
professional image and establish one's reputation as a professional.
Workman (1984) found that teachers who dressed in professional
clothing received higher scores on being intellectual and
credible, and better prepared for class.
Purpose. The purpose of the research was to investigate
high school principals perception in regard to dress of female
teachers. Ten occupational attributes, responsibility, competency,
knowledgeability, professionalism, honesty, reliability,
intelligence, trustworthiness, willingness to work hard,
and efficiency, identified by Kwon (1994) were used.
Procedure. The questionnaire included demographic
variables of years as principal, gender, age, level of education,
size of school and location. Three female dress modes: traditional,
business casual, and leisure, were shown in line illustrations.
Principals ranked the occupational attributes for female
per dress mode on a five-point Likert scale. A stratified
random sample of 231 Texas principal names were selected
from the five school divisions. Seventy-four were returned.
Findings. Respondents were male (80%) and Caucasian
(93.06%). School boards and principals establish dress policy
with principals being responsible for enforcement. Principals
(51.37%) indicated satisfaction with faculty dress on campus
which was primarily business casual. In contrast, traditional
attire was worn by principals (68.92%). Choices of income,
comfort, school setting and lack of knowledge of appropriate
dress were listed as factors in influencing teacher dress.
Comfort was the number one factor in apparel selection.
The top three attributes for traditional dress: professionalism
(4.57), responsibility (4.19), and competence (4.07); for
business casual: professionalism (4.07), responsibility (3.92),
and efficiency (3.83); for leisure dress: willingness to
work (2.61), knowledgeability (2.60), and efficiency (2.60).
If traditional business attair is worn, the female teacher
is seen as being overwhelmingly professional, responsible,
and competent. When dressed in leisure attire a significant
drop in rankings occurred when compared to professional dress.
Efficiency and reliability were the only attributes cited
across all three modes of dress. Traditional business attire
indicates a more professional image.
Implications. Undergraduate education students and
classroom teachers need to improve knowledge of dress. Fashion
merchandising and teacher education professionals have the
knowledge to assist the school districts in concepts related
to appearance and dress.
References.
Kwon, Yoon-Hee (1994). The influence
of Appropriateness of Dress and Gender on the Self-Perception
of Occupational Attributes. Clothing and Textiles Research
Journal, 12 (3), 33-39.
Workman, J. E. (1984). Effects of appropriate and inappropriate
attire on attributions of personal dispositions. Clothing and Textile Research
Journal, 3 (1), 20-23.
24.
WHY SHOP THERE IF YOU CAN GET IT HERE
Linda Simpson, Jane Wayland, Barbara Kemmerer, Eastern
Illinois University
Purpose. Outshopping is defined as the customer buying
goods away from home that could be purchased locally. Previous
studies have examined retail outshopping to determine the
demographics of outshoppers (Anderson and Kaminsky, 1985;
Hopper and Lipscomb, 1991) and major causes of outshopping
(LaForge, Reese, and Stanton, 1984). The purpose of this
exploratory study was to determine if consumer attitudes
toward local retailers, outshopping, or the overall enjoyment
of shopping makes a difference in outshopping behavior in
a community.
Methodology. Outshopping behavior was measured using
three standard scales. Likert questions were developed using
Hopper and Liscomb's (1991) Outshopping Scale (a=.74), Hawes
and Lumpkin's (1984) Attitude Toward Local Shopping Scale
(a=.71), and O'Guinn and Fabor's (1989) Shopping Enjoyment
Scale (a=.80). Focus groups were conducted for aid in questionnaire
development. The questionnaire was administered using two
methods of data collection with the objective of reaching
as many residents as possible. A random sample of 1200 residents
who reside in a rural midwestern community (population 20,000)
was selected by taking every 3rd name from the "address" page
in the telephone book while 1926 names were selected for
the mail survey using every 5th name. The total sample yielded
712 usable surveys for a 23% response rate.
Findings. The majority of the respondents (65%) indicated
that they do not enjoy shopping and only 11% agreed that
shopping is enjoyable. In addition, a majority of the respondents
tended to have a positive attitude toward outshopping with
only 8% not favoring outshopping. In relation to attitudes
toward local retailers, approximately 42% of the respondents
had a neutral view and 46% has a less than positive view.
Of the nine categories of goods and services that were examined,
little outshopping occurred in the categories of groceries,
gas and auto services, and banking.
T-tests of the three scales were used to determine if there
were statistical significant differences between outshoppers
and non-outshoppers of restaurant services, clothing, building
and home improvement, and gifts as these product categories
indicated the highest frequency of outshopping behavior.
It was found that outshoppers in each of these categories
had a positive view of outshopping (p=.000) and a less positive
opinion of local retailers (p=.000). Outshoppers of gifts
(p=.002) and building and home products (p=.004) enjoyed
outshopping more than non-outshoppers.
Implications. Outshopping can be detrimental to the
local economy; therefore, it is vital to closely examine
and monitor the relationship of attitudes and patronage behavior
of the residents who reside in that community. The specific
results of a study such as this are limited to the community
in which the study was conducted since the retail climate
differs by community; however, the process of conducting
a retail trade analysis for different communities may be
successfully replicated. It also provides a basis to assist
local retailers in understanding and improving the competitive
retail environment.
25.
LIVING, WORKING, AND PARENTING WITH SECTION 8
Marilyn J. Bruin, University of Minnesota
According to the U.S. Census (2000) 11,510,000 families
with a child under 18 years live in poverty. Poor families
are often concentrated in neighborhoods lacking the best
schools, community resources, and jobs with a living wage.
Section 8 tenant-based programs provide householders a voucher
for the difference between 30% of adjusted income and fair
market rent. Tenants must find an acceptable unit and negotiate
with a landlord to accept the voucher. This abstract focuses
on parents who use Section 8 vouchers in a suburban county.
Procedures. The Housing and Redevelopment Authority
distributed 230 surveys to parents; 64 surveys (30% response
rate) were returned. Twenty-seven (43%) respondents wrote
responses to the statement, "Is there anything else you would
like to tell us about your housing, neighborhood, and family?" Descriptive
information from the surveys and responses described live
in the suburbs.
Findings and Implications. County residents were 98.7%
Caucasian, 79% were home owners; median household income
in the county was $43,554. In contrast 97% of the respondents
were female heads of households, 64% were Caucasian, 47%
have never married, and another 33% were divorced or separated.
The majority experienced discrimination. For example, 69%
felt discriminated against because they rent, 69% agreed
that people like themselves were discriminated against when
trying to buy a house, and 85% agreed that people like themselves
had limited opportunities in finding a place to live. Written
comments elaborated, "I know they don't like Blacks out here
and they don't want us out here. My kids love the school.
But some of the people out here lock their door when you
walk up to their car and ask them anything. Some will call
you a name. The way they look at you when you are walking
into a store." Another parent wrote, "It's a struggle because
I live in a middle to upper class neighborhood--where my
so called 'neighbors' don't want me. . .People scoff at me
when I use food stamps here. I feel like I can't make any
friends because they look down on me. In the city, I'm sure
I'd meet others in my "boat," but not here."
With a median income of $12,000, several parents were very
thankful for the vouchers. One parent wrote, "We have a beautiful
new town home, I love the neighborhood, I love the school" Another
wrote, "Subsidized housing has helped me be able to choose
the place I'm in now. I am so thankful fur(sic) this help
I don't know what I'd do without it. My and my son's quality
of life increased 100% with this help and also because I'm
making healthy choices also." Other respondents were frustrated
and dissatisfied. Parents were concerned about noisy neighbors
or that neighbors complained about noisy children. Safety
was also a common concern. For example a parent wrote, "I
get very scared in this building. It's always dirty and loud."
Parents appreciate suburban schools and neighborhood safety.
Many low-income parents feel safe, secure housing allows
them to focus on parenting and work. However, life in the
suburbs is not without problems; discrimination and isolation
were frequently mentioned problems.
26. DISHWASHING PRACTICES AND WATER USAGE
JoAnn Emmel, Julia Beamish, and Kathleen Parrott, Virginia
Tech
Purpose. The purpose of this research was to examine
the dishwasher usage patterns and cleaning satisfaction of
today's consumers in an effort to learn more about the water
usage for this task. Of particular interest was prerinsing
dishes before placing them into the dishwasher. With an increasing
concern about water usage in our nation, dishwashing practices
could be contributing to unnecessary water consumption. No
matter how water efficient a dishwasher might be, ultimately
it is the consumers' actions related to prerinsing, cycle
selection, and other operational decisions that determine
actual water usage.
Procedure. Information about consumer dishwasher usage
was collected in two separate samples using different methods.
Data for a local sample of 78 individuals were collected
during the summer of 2000 as part of an extensive interview
on kitchen design and usage. The random national sample involved
a telephone survey of 630 respondents during Fall 2000 to
gather information about the design, use, and composition
of the respondents' kitchens. The interview form and survey
asked some of the same questions about dishwashing, but the
local interview involved a more extensive list.
Findings. All but 6.7% of the national sample prerinsed
their dishes at least some of the time before placing them
into the dishwasher, and almost half prerinsed 5 or more
times per week or about every time they used the dishwasher.
Families and younger respondents were those most likely to
prerinse. The rinse and hold cycle, which uses from 2-4.5
gallons of water, was used by only one quarter of the users,
far less than the number prerinsing at the faucet, which
can use up to 25 gallons if the faucet is continuously running.
When asked why they prerinsed dishes, the top reason was
because dishes would not be washed right away, followed by
uncertainty over whether or not dishes would become clean,
and habit. A majority of both samples' users were satisfied
with dishwasher performance. Ninety-three percent of the
local sample only washed with full loads.
Implications. Today's dishwashers use about half of
the water they did 20 years ago, but the fact that many consumers
continue to prerinse dishes - despite being told by manufacturers
and consumer educators they do not need to - negates much
of the water savings. Consumers express satisfaction with
their dishwasher's performance, but concern about performance
leads to frequent prerinsing. Many consumers who lowered
hot water temperatures during the last energy crisis may
have experienced poor dishwasher satisfaction which may have
led to some of their prerinsing habits. More consumer education
is needed in the areas of cycle selection, prerinsing, and
dishwasher selection to help consumers with dishwashing efficiency,
choosing the correct appliance for their households' needs,
and conserving water.
27.
SOCIOLOGICAL AND CONSUMER DIMENSIONS OF THE MIDWIFERY
MOVEMENT
Kelly Shannon Manley, Michallene G. McDaniel, University
of Georgia and Gainesville College
Purpose. Previous studies of women's choice of birth
attendants (Galotti, Pierce, Reimer, and Luckner, 2000; Howell-White,
1997), though enlightening, have not applied consumer theories
to the decision-making process. Given the increase of market-driven
characteristics in healthcare in the United States, analyzing
childbearing women's decisions from sociological and consumer
perspectives will help to shed light on the multidimensional
aspects of the process.
Procedures. Content analysis was used to analyze newsletters
and pamphlets from 1999 and 2000 from a U.S. midwifery advocacy
organization. This particular group was chosen because it
is the only consumer-based national midwifery advocacy organization
in the United States (involving the general public as well
as midwives and other birth attendants). The information
contained in the newsletters and pamphlets was analyzed not
only for the content, but also for its theoretical or ideological
perspective.
Findings. The vast majority of information contained
in the newsletters and pamphlets may be broadly classified
into feminist (i.e., female empowerment) and consumer rhetoric.
These classifications were made based upon the larger cultural
ideals embedded in the rhetoric of the literature. The organization
appears to approach empowerment through multiple avenues
so that women who may not feel a connection with feminist
rhetoric may instead identify with the ideals of consumerism
and consumer empowerment. Two main themes in the materials
contained in both types of rhetoric were choice and authority.
The consumer perspective is helpful in mainstreaming midwifery
into healthcare decisions from its more typical alternative
associations.
Implications. It appears from this preliminary analysis
that it is necessary to apply both sociological and consumer
theories of information seeking and decision making behavior
in order to understand fully women who are making birth attendant
choices. Given that use of midwives tends to be more cost
effective than traditional obstetrical care (Howell-White,
1999), it is of the utmost importance to explore viable,
cost-effective alternatives for childbearing women, particularly
since the number of uninsured citizens is predicted to rise
over the next decade (Reuters Health, 2000).
References.
Galotti, K.M., Pierce, B., Reimer,
R.L., and Luckner, A.E. (2000, July/August). Midwife or doctor:
A study of pregnant women making delivery decisions. Journal
of Midwifery and Women's Health, 45, 320-329.
Howell-White, S. (1999). Birth alternatives: How women select
childbirth care. Westport: Greewood Press.
Papps, E. and Olssen, M. (1997). Doctoring childbirth and
regulating midwifery in New Zealand. Palmerston (New Zealand): Dunmore Press.
Reuters Health. (2000, December 15). US uninsured could top
61 million by 2009. [on-line]. Available: news.excite.com/news/r/001215/13/health-uninsured.
28.
SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS AND HOUSING VALUES OF KOREAN HOUSEHOLDS
Sehwa Yang, Myojung Kim and Jinseon Hur, University
of Ulsan, Korea
Housing values are general guidelines for evaluation of
housing and serve to organize housing norms for specific
housing conditions and behaviors. According to Cutler, housing
values between socioeconomic classes are quite different,
while values within classes are roughly similar. The purpose
of this study was to examine the relationship between housing
values and socioeconomic status of Korean households. As
Cutler developed, ten housing values were analyzed: beauty,
convenience, comfort, location, health, personal interest,
privacy, safety, friendship, and cost. For the socioeconomic
status of the households, education of the head, household
income, and occupation of the head were utilized. A self-administered
questionnaire was developed, and distributed to 450 households
living in Ulsan, Korea. The final sample consisted of 411
households. Results from descriptive statistics and one-way
analysis of variance with Sheffé test were examined to address
the purpose of this study.
The significant effects of education of head were found on
beauty and privacy values. The households with more educated
head had higher values on beauty and privacy. The occupation
of the head affected only location value. The Sheffé test
revealed that the households headed with professional jobs
reported higher housing values of location. It was found
that four housing values including health, privacy, safety,
and cost were significantly related to household income.
Specifically, households with higher income were more likely
to rank these four housing values high. Additionally, the
relationship between these three socioeconomic variables
and how much housing values were net by current housing conditions
were also analyzed.
According to the results, among the variables representing
the socioeconomic status of households, it was appeared that
either education level or occupation of the head had less
important effects on housing values in Korea. Households
with higher income were more likely to consider various aspects
of housing. However, they perceived that their current housing
conditions did not meet what they're thinking important.
The results of this study have implications for housing educators
in Korea to study housing values in the context of other
housing characteristics and housing behaviors. Also, either
policy makers or planners should keep in mind the underlying
roles of housing values of households.
29.
APPLIANCE DISPOSAL BY JAPANESE CONSUMERS
Pat McCallister, Eastern Illinois University
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to determine
the reasons, attitudes and procedures for appliance disposal
by Japanese consumers. Japan is one of the highest population
density countries in the world. It has a limited means for
recycling products and often incinerators waste. In addition
housing for families is small and crowded, which leaves little
room for extra luxuries. Japanese consumers are often known
for their desire to have the latest in technology and reluctance
to purchase used items.
Procedures. An English worded, self-administered questionnaire
was given to 107 selected adults in Japan. The respondents
were provided a check-list and asked to indicate the reasons,
attitudes and procedures used in their disposal of appliances.
The participants who completed the questionnaire communicated
in English as a second language; however, the researcher
was available to clarify or answer questions from the respondents.
Frequencies were used for data analysis. The total number
of responses exceeded 107 since respondents could check all
answers that applied.
Some demographics of the consumers in the survey were that
office worker (67.35%) was listed as the most frequent occupation
for the man and housewife (35.5%) as the primary occupation
for the woman. Twenty percent of the respondents lived in
four-member households and ten percent resided in five-member
households. Almost half of the respondents lived in a 4 to
7 room apartment or house.
Findings. Some findings were when Japanese consumers
disposed of an appliance: 43 consumers gave it to a member
outside the household, 39 threw it in the trash, 28 took
it to be recycled, 10 advertised and sold it, and 7 gave
it to the Salvation Army or other donation site. The most
frequent reasons for disposal of an appliance were: 68 stated
it was broken and would not work and 27 respondents, the
second most frequent response, indicated a newer and better
model came on the market. When a consumer threw an appliance
in the trash pile, the expectations for disposal were that
it would be recycled, hauled away by the trash collector
or collected by a Japanese person.
Implications. This study is important to understand
the actions of consumers in other countries because our global
society shares the one Earth. Professionals who work with
international governments, industries and consumers need
to understand consumer decision making practices in relation
to appliance disposal so that education programs for consumers,
legislative policy and appliance manufacturing practices
can be reviewed and proposed.
30.
ESTIMATED AVERAGE DAILY INTAKES OF DIETARY ENERGY AND
FAT DO NOT DIFFER BETWEEN SELF-REPORTED CHRONIC DIETERS
AND NON-DIETERS
Jeannemarie M. Beiseigel and Sharon M. Nickols-Richardson,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and
State University
Continual dieting for weight management through restriction
of caloric or dietary fat intake is common among young-adult
females. It remains in question, however, if females who
self-report "chronic dieting" consume fewer kilocalories
and grams of dietary fat on a daily basis compared to females
who do not diet. The purpose of this study, therefore, was
to test the hypothesis that young-adult females with self-reported
histories of chronic dieting would have significantly lower
(p < 0.05) average daily dietary energy and fat intakes
compared to non-dieters.
Young-adult (aged 18 to 25 years), moderately active, Caucasian
females participated in this exploratory cross-sectional
study. Participants reported the amount of time during the
previous 12 months that they spent dieting as: a) never;
b) < 50% of the time, or c) > 50% of the time (Grunewald,
1985). Females who reported dieting greater than 50% of the
time during the previous year were classified as chronic
dieters (n=13). Females who reported never dieting during
the previous year were classified as non-dieters (n=36).
All other respondents were excluded. The Food Frequency Questionnaire
(Block, 1998) was used to collect dietary intake data during
the past year. Average daily dietary energy and fat intakes
were calculated for each participant from her Food Frequency
Questionnaire using the DIETSYS+Plus Analysis Software (version
5.9, 1999, Block Dietary Data Systems, Berkeley, CA, USA).
Height (cm) and weight (kg) were measured with a stadiometer
and digital scale, respectively, and along with age, were
used to calculate each participant's estimated daily energy
and fat requirements (Food ProcessorÒ dietary analysis software,
version 7.5, esha Research, Salem, OR, USA). Student's t-tests
were conducted to identify differences in mean body height
and weight, daily energy intake, daily dietary fat intake,
and percent of estimated energy and fat requirements between
chronic dieters and non-dieters (Statistical Analysis System,
version 8.0, SAS, Cary, NC, USA).
Chronic dieters were significantly shorter than non-dieters
(168+1 vs. 162+2 cm, respectively; mean + SEM, p<0.05);
however, mean body weight was not significantly different
between groups (65±3 vs. 63±2 kg, respectively). Total average
daily energy (1792±179 vs. 1861±103 kcal) and dietary fat
(65±3 vs. 63±7 g) intakes of chronic dieters and non-dieters,
respectively, also did not significantly differ between groups.
Furthermore, when calculated as a percentage of estimated
requirements, to account for the significant difference in
body height, significant differences in average daily percent
intake of energy (82±5 vs. 80±9 %) and dietary fat (83±10
vs. 86±5 %) between chronic dieters and non-dieters, respectively,
were not found.
Results from this exploratory study suggest that when food
intake is averaged over time, young-adult, moderately active,
Caucasian females who identify themselves as chronic dieters
may not consume significantly less dietary energy and fat
compared to non-dieters. Survey tools that better distinguish
chronic dieters from non-dieters are needed.
Grunewald, K. K. (1985). Weight control in young college
women: Who are the dieters? Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 85,
1445-1450.
Block Dietary Data Systems. (1998). The Block98.2 Food Frequency
Questionnaire. Berkeley, CA.
31.
ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE PRACTICES OF NUTRITION and EXERCISE
STUDENTS
Barbara A. Davis, Tim Roberts, and F.A. Bruce Jr.,
Virginia Tech
This study was designed to assess the use of alternative
medicine therapies among college students. A survey instrument
was developed and distributed to students (n=474) enrolled
in three core nutrition courses within the Human Nutrition,
Foods and Exercise Department at Virginia Tech. Questions
related to past and current use of a variety of herbal preparations,
other alternative medicine practices as well as vitamin and
mineral supplements. Participants were also queried about
their reasons for using these therapies to assess their knowledge
of alternative medicine practices.
Forty percent of college nutrition and exercise majors participating
in this survey (n=352) reported use of herbal supplements,
while 54% of participants used a multivitamin supplement.
Ginseng and garlic were the most frequently used herbal preparations
followed by green tea, echinacea, ginger, St. John's Wort,
Gingko biloba, Ma Huang (ephedra), tea tree oil, and kava
kava. Green tea and echinacea were used more frequently by
females, whereas ephedra was used more frequently by males
(p<0.05). Females were more likely to consume multivitamin
supplements than males (58 vs. 46%, respectively, p<0.05).
Calcium supplementation was also more common in women than
men (25.7 vs. 15.7%, respectively, p<0.05). However, males
consumed creatine more frequently than females (34 vs. 5%,
respectively, p<0.05). Interestingly, there was no significant
difference in consumption of folate supplements between females
and males, despite the fact that women in this study were
of childbearing age.
Other alternative medicine practices reported by study participants
included imagery, meditation, chiropractics, art/music therapy,
yoga, therapeutic touch, traditional Chinese medicine, magnetic
therapy, and acupuncture. Females practiced imagery/relaxation
techniques, meditation, and yoga more often (p<0.01),
whereas males were more likely to see a chiropractor (p<0.01).
No other significant differences in gender-related use of
these practices were noted.
Results from this study demonstrate that a significant proportion
of nutrition and exercise majors use alternative nutrition
and medical therapies. The results of this study correlate
with data published regarding use of such therapies by other
populations (Eisenberg et al., 1998; DHHS, 1999) and underscore
the importance of incorporating alternative medicine education
in the curriculum of nutrition and exercise majors.
Eisenberg, D.M., Davis, R.B., Ettner, S.L., Appel, S., Wilkey,
S., Rompay, M.V., and Kessler, R.C. (1998). Trends in alternative medicine use
in the United States, 1990-1997. Journal American Medical Association, 280 (18),
1569-75.
US Dept. of Health and Human Services (DHHS), National Center
for Health Statistics. (1999). Use of dietary supplements in the United States,
1988-94. Series 11: Data From the National Health Examination Survey, the National
Health and Nutrition Examination Surveys, and the Hispanic Health and Nutrition
Examination Survey No. 244. DHHS No. (PHS) 99-1694. Hyattsville, MD: Centers
For Disease Control and Prevention.
32. WHO IN THE U.S IS CONSUMING
FUNCTIONAL FOODS?
Jeannette Endres and Sharon Barter, Southern Illinois
University
Purpose. Market surveys can indicate consumption
trends of targeted foods. Functional foods are defined as
foods providing benefits beyond basic nutrition (ADA, 1999).
Consumption of functional foods has been advocated. Surveys
on foods that consumers believe have health promoting properties
are available (ADA, 2000 and IFIC, 1998). Consumers intend
to eat foods with health promoting properties; however, how
often do they actually consume functional foods?
This study reports the per capita consumption of approximately
40 targeted functional foods during 1999, and what has been
the 10-year trend in consumption of these foods. A detailed
analysis of 10 targeted foods provides descriptive data on
who is eating specific functional foods.
Procedures. Food consumption data were analyzed from
National Eating Trend survey including over 2000 households
collected on a representative sample of the US population.
Ten foods frequently eaten and rated as most important by
researchers working in the area were targeted for further
study. The presentation will include consumption patterns
gathered on tomatoes, chocolate, tuna, garlic, broccoli,
yogurt, grapes, cabbage, whole wheat bread, and cranberries.
Findings. Data show that consumption of frequently
identified functional foods has decreased or stayed the same
for the last 10 years. The population rarely eats some foods
identified as functional foods, cranberries, blueberries,
and salmon. Data show that the use of targeted foods varies
by age, income, family size, urban verses rural areas, race,
education, occupation, and head of household. The demographics
of the population and the consumption patterns will be discussed
in relation to planning consumer education to increase consumption
of foods containing health-promoting properties.
Implications. Most research efforts have been targeted
toward studying functional properties of foods as well as
the attitudes and beliefs of consumers toward consumption
of specific foods. If we are to target future educational
programs to encourage consumption of functional foods, knowledge
of current consumption trends of targeted functional foods
could prove useful and provide direction for future educational
program planning.
References.
American Dietetic Association (ADA).
Position of the American Dietetic Association: Functional
foods. J Am Diet Assoc. 999;99:1278-1285.
American Dietetic Association (ADA). Americans' food and
nutrition attitudes and behaviors: American Dietetic Association's Nutrition
and you-Trends 2000 survey. Accessed 4/21/01 at www.eatright.org/pr/2000/010300a.html.
International Food Information Council (IFIC) Foundation.
Functional Foods: Attitudinal Research. Food Insight. 1999.
Research was supported by the Illinois Council on Food and
Agricultural Research.
33.
IS FOOD SAFETY KNOWLEDGE PUT INTO PRACTICE BY
CONSUMERS IN MIDDLE TENNESSEE?
Sandria L. Godwin, Thelma Sanders-Hunter,
Leslie Speller-Henderson, Tennessee State University
Introduction. Much emphasis has been placed on food
safety in recent years, yet millions of cases of food-borne
illness occur each year in the United States alone. The Partnership
for Food Safety Education was launched in 1997, which combines
the resources of the government, industry and consumer organizations.
From this effort has emerged the Fight Bac!TM campaign, which
targets consumers of many different types.
Purpose. In order to assess the awareness and implementation
of the4se messages, a comprehensive knowledge and practice
survey instrument was developed, pretested, and revised which
used the messages from the Fight Bac!TM program. Questions
included multiple choice, true-false (with an "I don't know")
option, and likert-scale. One hundred forty-six persons of
various races, age groups and both sexes completed the survey.
Results. Results indicate that consumer's food safety
knowledge conflicts with their food safety practices. The
data suggest that some messages are clearer than others.
A high percentage of respondents understood the importance
of hand washing, but not the recommended length of time.
In practice, hands were actually washed depending on the
source of the germs, ie. food, pets, diapers, cigarettes,
etc. Consumers appear to be least knowledgeable about specific
times and temperatures. Highest scores for knowledge and
practice were received on questions relating to cross-contamination.
Implications. Although many consumers are aware of
what food safety practices they should be doing, in many
cases, they were not implementing that knowledge. Additional
intervention appears to be needed to ensure that food safety
knowledge corresponds to food safety practice.
This projected was funded by USDA.
34.
PREVALENCE OF FOOD INSECURITY AND DIETARY PRACTICE OF
LOW INCOME PERSONS PARTICIPATING IN FOOD ASSITANCE PROGRAM
Nweze Nnakwe, Illinois State University
Food insecurity is defined as the limited or uncertain availability
of nutritionally adequate and safe foods or limited or uncertain
ability to acquire acceptable foods in socially acceptable
ways. Food insecurity is a problem of critical importance
for our society. Addressing food insecurity requires knowing
the prevalence of the problem and the groups that are affected.
The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence
of food insecurity and dietary practices of low-income persons.
Prior to conducting the research, the procedures were reviewed
and approved by the University's Human Subjects Institutional
Review Board. Upon verbal consent for participating in the
study, participants were surveyed by utilizing Radimer/Cornell
hunger questionnaire to determine the prevalence of food
insecurity. Food frequency questionnaire was used to assess
the dietary practices. Demographic data including marital
status, and education level were collected using a multilevel
assessment instrument. A total of two hundred and thirty
five subjects were interviewed. Statistical analysis for
food intake was calculated by One Way Analysis of Variance.
The prevalence of food insecurity was determined by Pearson
Chi-square.
Results show that six percent of 55-69 year old experienced
food insecurity with moderate hunger and food insecurity
without hunger. Twenty four percent of the households with
children experienced food insecurity without hunger. Twelve
percent experienced food insecurity with moderate and severe
hunger. Households with children experienced food insecurity
more than those without children, this was statistically
significant at p<0.01. Twelve percent of individuals with
less than high school education experienced food insecurity
without hunger. Seven percent experienced food insecurity
with moderate hunger. Thirteen percent of the individuals
with high school education and those with some college education
experienced food insecurity without hunger. Twelve percent
experienced food insecurity with moderate hunger and nine
percent experienced food insecurity with severe hunger. Households
without children consumed more dairy products, meat, and
citrus fruits than the households with children, this was
statistically significantly at p<0.001, p<0.01 and
p<0.001, respectively. Households with children consumed
significantly more grains, and fatty snack foods, this was
significant at p<0.01, and p<0.05, respectively. Women
consumed significantly more dairy products than men; the
difference was significant at p<0.04. Men consumed slightly
more citrus fruits, vegetables and grains than women. The
implications of this study were that food insecurity exists
among older persons and low-income people.
35.
QUALITY OF LIFE AND NUTRITION RISK IN ELDERLY HOME-DELIVERED
MEAL RECIPIENTS AND A WAITING LIST GROUP
Elaine S. Smith, Alice A. Spangler, and Rebecca A.
Adams, Ball State University
The purpose of the study was to evaluate the impact of receiving
a home-delivered meal on the quality of life and nutritional
risk of homebound elders. Forty-three subjects (age 60-94
years of age) receiving home-delivered meals were matched
as a group with 43 subjects (age 65-94 years of age) on a
waiting list for a home-delivered meal program in Pennsylvania.
Matching criteria were functional needs measure, age, gender,
and living arrangement of the two groups. Each group had
29 women and 14 men. In both groups approximately 50% lived
alone and approximately 40% lived with a spouse; no subjects
lived with non-relatives.
Home visits were conducted to collect the data. Nutritional
risk was assessed by the Nutrition Screening Initiative's
Determine Checklist. Quality of life was measured across
various domains including a global quality of life self-rating,
Geriatric Depression Scale, functional ability including
ADL's (Activities of Daily Living and IADL's (Instrumental
Activities of Daily Living), and a food enjoyment scale.
The study also documented the resources for meal preparation
and grocery shopping possessed by the meal recipient group
and the waiting list group.
Results indicate the two groups were similar statistically
(p>.05) in level of nutrition risk; 49% of the meal recipient
group were at high nutrition risk; 56% of the waiting list
group were at high nutrition risk. Two-tailed t-tests failed
to show differences in quality of life between the groups
at the 0.05 level of significance. A significant difference
(p=0.039) was seen in the number of resources reported for
meal preparation assistance with the waiting list group reporting
the use of more informal resources such as family and other
informal caregivers.
The research will be useful to meal program planners because
it identifies specific problems of nutrition risk in this
population. Meal recipients seemed to be those truly in need
with less ability to provide for self. Most of the meal recipients
were dependent on the home-delivered meal as demonstrated
by the findings that more in the home-delivered meal group
expressed an inability to cook and shop for food. The findings
on resources and caregiving may help family and consumer
sciences and other program planners and providers assist
elders to identify informal resources for cooking and meal
preparation. The study shows that informal resources other
than the home-delivered meal enable non-recipients to maintain
a quality of life and level of nutrition similar to their
meal recipient peers.
36.
THE USE OF AN INSTANT MODIFIED FOOD STARCH IN CREATING
A REDUCED SUGAR RASPBERRY JAM
Janet C. Stocks, Maribeth C. Clarke, CFCS, Carolyn
Garrison, Brigham Young University
There is a demand for fruit spreads which contain less sugar
and fewer calories. This is not easily achieved. Most reduced
sugar jams and jellies rely on Low Methoxyl (LM) pectin to
provide gelling, but the resulting fruit spreads are often
rubbery with poor flavor retention. The purpose of this research
was to develop a formula for superior quality reduced sugar
jams and jellies which exceed commercial standards, with
the use of a modified food starch (Ultra GelÒ) and a High
Methoxyl (HM) pectin. Although starches are not commonly
used in jams and jellies, some of their properties are helpful
in preventing syneresis and creating a heat stable jam or
jelly.
A formulation for reduced sugar jams and jellies with the
use of a modified food starch and HM pectin was developed.
The reduced sugar jam recipe was formulated without any artificial
ingredients or chemical additives. The manufacturing process
was free from complicated procedures. The formula used natural
sweeteners (sucrose), but in reduced amounts. Existing nutritional
standards for reduced sugar products of no more than 30 kilocalories
per tablespoon was used as a benchmark. Citric acid was used
to maintain an appropriate pH level and to brighten the color
of the fruit. Experimentation was performed in a controlled
new product development laboratory until the appropriate
proportions of hydrocolloids, sugar, fruit mixtures, and
liquid were achieved. Four final reduced sugar jam products
(two newly developed and two commercial products) were then
evaluated in a commercial standard food science sensory evaluation
laboratory on standards of aroma, color, clarity, flavor,
stability, texture and consistency. A sample panel of 54
participants, ages 18-64 was used. Evaluators registered
their responses on touch screen computer panels. Information
obtained was statistically analyzed to determine potential
consumer acceptance of these products.
Sensory testing revealed that 92% of the evaluators preferred
the two newly developed reduced sugar jam products over the
existing commercial formulations and all evaluation standards.
The newly developed formulations contained 30% fewer calories
and nearly half the carbohydrates and sugar of other commercially
available reduced sugar fruit spreads. Sensory evaluation
of the products indicated that a reduced sugar jam of this
nature would be well received by the consumer market.
Market research indicates a demand for superior quality reduced
sugar products. Taste and cost evaluations indicate that
the products developed in this study can meet that demand
at an acceptable cost. Additionally, low sugar formulations
can compete favorably with full sugar products. The data
acquired gives adequate justification for further marketing
research and development of this product.
37.
FAMILIES AS POTENTIAL OBSTACLES TO END-OF-LIFE CARE
Maribeth C. Clarke, CFCS; Renea L. Beckstrand, Laura
N. Conover, CFCS,
Brigham Young University
Critical care nurses have identified specific family behaviors
as directly impacting the end-of-life care process (Kirchhoff
and Beckstrand, 2000). What the family does, says, and thinks
may play a major role in the success and quality of medical
care offered at the end of life. Because the older adult
population is projected to reach over 70 million people in
the next thirty years (Donaldson and Field, 1998), family
and health care professionals must work together to resolve
the obstacles and enhance the helpful behaviors surrounding
end-of-life care.
The purpose of this study was to access the unique perceptions
of the critical care nurse, as he/she is the liaison between
the medical staff, patient, and patient's family, in determining
both the intensity and the frequency of the family behaviors
identified by Kirchhoff and Beckstrand (2000) as obstacles
to providing end-of-life care. Specifically, the study sought
to identify ways in which families can enhance these helpful
behaviors and minimize their impact as obstacles in the end-of-life
care process.
A national sample of 1500 staff nurses who had cared for
patients at the end of life was randomly selected from the
membership of the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses
(AACN). Participants were sent a revised version of the National
Survey of Critical Care Nurses Regarding End-of-Life Care.
Two follow-up mailings for non-respondents were completed.
A 61% response rate was achieved (n=861 useable surveys).
Obstacles and help items were ranked on the basis of their
mean scores to determine which items were perceived as the
most intense. Each item intensity score was multiplied by
the cumulative frequency score to obtain a perceived severity
score. The perceived severity scores were then ranked from
highest to lowest.
The two most severe obstacles to providing quality end-of-life
care were identified as the family continually calling the
nurse and the family not understanding the term "life-saving
measures." The four highest ranked helps to the end-of-life
care giving process were allowing the family adequate time
alone after the death of the patient, maintaining a peaceful,
dignified bedside scene for the family, teaching the family
how to act around the patient, and the family thanking the
nurse after working with the patient. Other top-ranked obstacles
and helps also dealt with the family and medical personnel
interface, the behavior either initiated by the family or
by the medical staff.
This data identifies and offers suggestions toward resolution
of some of the concerns surrounding end-of-life care. If
family professionals and the medical community work together
to educate the family regarding these issues, the quality
of the end-of-life care process can be enhanced and thus
help the family have a more meaningful experience with the
death of a loved one.
Kirchoff, K. T., and Beckstrand, R. L. (2000). Critical care
nurses' perceptions of obstacles and helpful behaviors in providing end-of-life
care to dying patients. American Journal of Critical Care, 9(2), 96-105.
Donaldson, M.S., and Field, M. J. (1998). Measuring quality
of care at the end of life. Arch Intern Med, 158, 121-128.
38.
ADOLESCENTS AND CONFLICT WITH PEERS: RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN
PERSONALITY FACTORS AND CONFLICT RESOLUTION STRATEGIES*
Debra DeBates, South Dakota State University
Purpose. The purpose of this study was to explore
the relationship between three major personality dimensions
of Psychoticism, Neuroticism and Extraversion as influencing
the conflict management resolution style of adolescents when
involved in conflict with a best friend of the same gender.
The conflict management resolution styles were based on styles
used by business and industry in assessing conflict with
peers. They included the following: Compromising/Collaborating,
Accommodating, Dominating, and Avoiding. The adolescent's
self-esteem was explored as mediating these effects.
Procedures. The sample for the study consisted of
393 eighth grade students from five middle schools in South
Dakota. Measures used in the study were the junior version
of the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire (EPQ-JR.), Rosenberg's
Self-esteem Scale and a modified version of the Rahim Organizational
Conflict Inventory – II. A model was identified to explore
the direct relationships between the personality dimensions
and conflict resolution style and their effects on conflict
resolution style as mediated by self-esteem. In the model,
the three personality dimensions (Psychoticism, Neuroticism
and Extraversion) served as exogenous variables and self-esteem
as a mediator in predicting each of the conflict resolution
management styles. A comparison of the model was conducted
for males and females as well as for comparing groups based
on school achievement using grade point averages. All data
analysis procedures were completed using the SPSS 9.0 computer
program with the exception of the structural equation model
path analysis. The SPSS AMOS 3.6 program was used for these
procedures.
Findings. In the first segment of the data analysis,
means for each of the three personality dimensions and self-esteem
were compared to examine differences related to age, gender,
family structure and grade point averages of the participants.
Using this data, several significant differences emerged.
Younger students had significantly lower self-esteem than
older students. Males had significantly higher scores on
the Psychoticism dimension of personality while females had
significantly higher scores on the Neuroticism dimension
than males. No significant differences for self-esteem for
males and females were found in this study. Students from
two-parent families had significantly higher self-esteem
scores than those from one-parent families. A significant
main effect for grade point average (GPA) on Psychoticism
was found with students with a GPA of C or lower reporting
significantly higher scores on this personality dimension
than either A or B students. A and B students were also found
to have significantly higher scores on the Extraversion dimension
of personality. Additional analyses explored differences
in conflict resolution style by gender, age, family structure
and GPA. A significant difference for gender on the Compromising/Collaborating
conflict management style was reported with females more
likely to choose this style than males. Males in one-parent
families had significantly lower scores on the Avoiding conflict
management style than males of females from two-parent families
and females in one-parent families.
A major purpose of this study was to assess the effectiveness
of the proposed model in predicting conflict management style
of adolescents. In a comparison of the model for each of
the four conflict management styles, the strongest support
for the model was evidenced in the Compromising/Collaborating
conflict resolution style. All of the personality dimensions
individually and self-esteem were significant in their relationship
to this conflict resolution style. In addition, the role
of self-esteem as having a mediating effect on the personality
dimensions and the choice of the Compromising/Collaborating
style was supported. However, with the remaining three models
using the Avoiding, Accommodating and Dominating styles,
the role of self-esteem as a mediator was very minimal. While
self-esteem may play a role in predicting conflict resolution
styles, it did not appear to be a mediator in the relationship
between the personality dimensions explored and the conflict
resolution styles.
Implications. Results indicated that the ROCI-II instrument
appears to measure styles of handling conflict in interpersonal
relationships regardless of whether these conflicts occur
at work or with friends and with adolescents as well as adults.
Further research is needed to explore whether adolescents
use similar styles of conflict resolution with peers regardless
of setting or situation (with friends, classmates, parents,
co-workers, etc.) With the exception of a significant impact
of Psychoticism on the Compromising/Collaborating style,
it is apparent that this model does little to account for
variance in the conflict management styles of adolescents
particularly for students with a GPA of C or below. This
points to the need for further study to explore what accounts
for differences in conflict management styles for those students
performing at the C or below level academically. *Dissertation
research at Iowa State University
39.
THE INFLUENCE OF AFFLUENCE ON GEN-XER'S
Carma Sutherland and Janiel Nelson, Ricks College
The purpose of this survey was to determine the effect(s)
of being raised in wealth and abundance. The researchers
designed 43 open-ended questions and surveyed 105 voluntary
students at Ricks College. Results indicated that the average
age students remembered seeing their first television commercial
and wanting that item was 5 ½. Students felt excited/happy
along with guilty/depressed after returning from a day's
shopping and confessed that shopping made them feel good
for different reasons, one of which was they were "good at
it." The majority of students surveyed did not realize they
had been raised in affluence, nor did they perceive themselves
as materialistic, yet 40% of respondents had often felt deprived
as a child.
©2001 American Association of Family
and Consumer Sciences. All rights reserved.
For educational use only. Commercial use, resale, reproduction,
or distribution is prohibited. Purchase
online or email info@aafcs.org.
AAFCS Research Abstracts sold to Members for $10.00 and Nonmembers
for $15.00.
|